O'Donoghue's Pub and Restaurant, New York City

Overview

4.0

647 reviews

Excellent46%
Very good36%
Average14%
Poor3%
Terrible1%

Travelers talk about

“guinness stew” (7 reviews)

“bangers and mash” (12 reviews)

“burger” (39 reviews)

Restaurant Hours

+ Add hours

CUISINES

American, Irish, Bar, Pub, Vegetarian Friendly

PRICE

$$ - $$$

RATINGS

Service

Food

Value

Atmosphere

LOCATION

156 W 44th St, New York City, NY 10036-4024

All Details

Improve This Listing

Write a ReviewReviews (647)

1 - 10 of 553 reviews

666Rocky

Stockport, United Kingdom

1616

Reviewed today

Great Irish bar

Visited a few rises throughout our stay for either just drinks or food. Good service, great selection of beer. Friendly staff. Small but perfectly formed. Great live music.

Thank 666Rocky

JimRiesterer

Edina, Minnesota

672305

Reviewed today via mobile

Traditional Irish pub

A nice Irish pub just a bit off Times Square. It seems every block has at least one Irish pub and this one was cozy with plenty of TVs for watching the World Cup. We stopped in on a Friday for a late lunch and...More

Thank JimRiesterer

cross182

Sydney, Australia

723

Reviewed 1 week ago

Great pre theater biye and a beverage

TRADITIONAL; Irish pub.... Good food ( Fish & Chips cause its Friday) and a Guinness did the trick.The service was excellent, and very fast.... Must return to explore more items on the menu.

Thank cross182

Great to hear you had fun and thanks so much for the review and feedback. Nice to see you enjoyed the Fish & Chips and the Guinness! Have a nice rest of your weekend, and thank you again.

Jude R

Long Island, NY

13938

Reviewed 2 weeks ago

Just okay, could have been much better...

Stopped in for a bite to eat before a concert at the Playstation Theater. The place was very crowded (all seats at the long bar were full) and most of the table were taken, but we were seated immediately. Our waitress was very attentive and...More

Thank Jude R

Jude, thanks for coming by and for the review. We are glad you enjoyed most of your experience and wish you a wonderful weekend. Thanks again.

TravellingBenUK99

2336

Reviewed 2 weeks ago via mobile

good atmosphere and service shame about the food

We are at O'Donaghue's twice during our trip. Our first experience wasn't great. The service was excellent, lovely waitress who we couldn't fault. However the food let it down. I had the cheesy garlic bread to start which was piping hot but soft, which suggested...More

Thank TravellingBenUK99

Thanks for joining us twice, and we are glad the second time around was a better experience. We really appreciate your feedback. Also for the record, we do not use a microwave to cook anything, but apologize if the bread was on the softer side....More

Paul O

218

Reviewed 3 weeks ago

Greta night watching Football and drinking.

Great Drinks and bar food are to be had here, We visited to watch Champions League and it was buzzing. Not the biggest of establishments but certainly carries great atmosphere. Only down side is you feel under pressure to keep ordering more beers as the...More

Thank Paul O

Paul, many thanks on the kind review and the feedback. Glad you had fun and enjoyed. We wish you a wonderful weekend and summer. Thanks again.

Andy M

1

Reviewed 3 weeks ago via mobile

Friendly place

Been several times great staff they very friendly and I still keep in touch with them, the food was amazing especially the mac and cheese and burgers 2 die for 😀

Thank Andy M

Andy, we really appreciate your support and nice review. Thanks so much for the feedback and we'll see ya again.

dolphinorlando

London, United Kingdom

20871

Reviewed 3 weeks ago via mobile

Always had a fabulous time in here!

The food is good and decent for price. We’ve been coming here since 2013. Never changes very good customer service and super bar selection ;)

Thank dolphinorlando

Great to hear and we are so thankful for your business and review. Enjoy the rest of the week, and thanks again.

billbaileyPlymouth

Plymouth

4229

Reviewed 3 weeks ago

What a find

Having had a terrible breakfast experience at Bread and Butter, finding somewhere that provided decent food for our evening meal was high on the list of priorities. What a find this place was. From the staff that greeted us to the bar staff and waiting...More

Thank billbaileyPlymouth

We're glad you came by and so thrilled you all enjoyed yourselves and had fun. Thank you for the nice review and feedback!!

Yorkybarkid107

7637

Reviewed 4 weeks ago via mobile

Good food great pub

Ate here a couple of times as our hotel was just across the road. One time it was quite late but they were still happy to serve food. Good quality home cooked food.

Thank Yorkybarkid107

Great to hear that, and thanks so much for coming by and the review. Enjoy the summer and we hope to see you again some time.

Previous Next

1 2 3 4 5 6 …56

Restaurant Menu

Sorry, we were unable to load the menu data.

Nearby

Midtown

This is the iconic New York that so many visitors
imagine before they visit - spectacular skyscrapers
like the Chrysler Building and Empire State Building,
iconic public buildings like Grand Central Terminal
and the New York Public Library, and the non-stop
hustle and bustle of the city streets. Fifth Avenue is
a shopper's paradise where you can find every kind of
store imaginable, with fashion brands ranging from the

...More