Not sure if we just happen to get lucky but quite possibly one of the best meals I have had in NYC or anywhere for that matter. Quaint restaurant where we we greeted by a friendly face as soon as we walked in. A gentleman...who we learned was the owner also welcomed us as we were checking our coats. The pace, timing and everything was on point. We have some delicious oysters, a reasonably priced wine, a filet for me and lamb for my wife. We were trying to decide on appetizers and rather than push us to order too much, our waiter suggested that if our sides were not enough that he would get us another promptly, quite the opposite of many NYC restaurants where we were pushed to order way too much. Bravo Club A! The steak could have almost been cut with a fork, very flavorful without too much salt, just outstanding! And the lamb was amazing! Being our first visit they brought us a dessert on the house! Wow, just unusual and outstanding. HIGHLY recommend. We spent more elsewhere and received half the experience of Club A.More

Family trip to The Big Apple went to this comfortable steak restaurant. Great steak and delicious sides. Attentive but not over bearing service. Menu priced so that dinner doesn’t break the bank. Look forward to a return visit.

Nice place. Confident, welcoming and professional manager. Our waiter was negatively sarcastic and not professional. Welcome mushroom tordello (good). Mac&Cheese side was good. We took a decision to change and go for something different, cheeseburger. Arrived with no cheese and no sauce. Took the burger...back, added some cheese, and managed to burn it. The burger, as meat taste, was not appreciated. Again, the waiter, indirectly un polite and sarcastic. The manager, professional, compt the burger (cheese). Would absolutely not recommend a cheeseburger l. Probably their steaks could deserve a shot.More

An absolute must, no wonder it’s so highly rated!! Visited for my husband 50th birthday celebrations, everything was spot on. We ordered a porterhouse, didn’t realise how big it would be, would have skipped starters if we knew, the taste was amazing!! Wine is expensive...we stuck to the good range of beers and IPA . Complimentary deserts was a nice touch.More

Excellent in all terms: atmosphere,food,service,at reasonable prices !Gorgeous cut of steak,perfectly rendered,juicy!The omnipresent owner treats his clients as family guests!

I really can’t tell what was better the service or the taste, everything was so delicious and delightful. Not too much to say other than everything was perfect!!!

Top quality Porterhouse steak and Rib Eye! Great service and an affordable winelist for NY! A great thank you to the A-Club team!

Absolutely amazing. We ate here the last time we were in the city and decided to visit again for our 10th wedding anniversary. They really make such a lovely effort, the owner even visits your table several times. The food is exquisite and the wine...menu is extensive. My favourite porterhouse - can’t wait to come back, thanks for a memorable evening.More

We were expecting more based on the reviews. Steak was good, nice enough place but trimmings few and far between. This was literally steak and fries. Prawn starter was three extremely large prawns with a ketchup dip and a seafood dip. The food was pretty...unimaginative but the bill with a few drinks was still $150+.More

Beautiful food - porterhouse the best steak we have ever had. Service really great! Yes it’s slightly speedy but would recommend to anyone looking for a great meal.

Food ( porterhouse steak) was very good. Dessert was complementary ( there is no dessert menu). It looks like the waiters are in training process, but they were polite and nice. Recommended.

Absolutely wonderful meal and service. Our pic was taken and we received a beautiful dessert. Bruno, the owner, came by and was great. He appreciated our business. Highly recommend.