Gave it only a 2 because of the fish sandwich was paper thin AND way too many flies inside. Wasn't impressed

We wanted somewhere with a view and inside dining. Pier Plaza checked both of those boxes. We started with an appetizer of Wisconsin Poutine. It was good. For entree's I had the surf and turf (steak and whitefish) and my husband had the whitefish. My...only complaint is I wish they had given us more time before serving the entries. We had about 2 bites of salad and then they brought the entrees. Things were starting to get cold by the time we scarfed down the salads. The food itself was really good. My steak was done as requested. It was my first time trying whitefish. I don't think I'd order that again as I found it really mushy. The waitress was attentive and brought things right when asked.More

It was a busy place so we sat at the bar. Food was excellent as was the service. The bartender was super busy but didn't seem to miss a beat. We had the ahi tuna bowl and fish and chips. Both were great.

We stopped here for appetizers after a long day of kayaking and hiking. It's not that the food was bad, however, their homemade chips for the cilantro lime chicken nachos are just that. Chips. I was expecting tortilla chips. Not a lot of shredded chicken...either nor was there any strong taste of cilantro lime flavor. Poutine was ok but I'm not to sure it was brisket they served. Tasted more like a pot roast. It wasn't bad, just didn't give me any inclination to go back.More

The burgers and sandwiches were good. The whitefish was good but I wouldnt get it again. The staff was friendly and atmosphere was great. Id eat here again forsure!

Very unimpressed with the food. Cold potatoes served with fish fry. Rib eye steak dinner not good. Steak over cooked —ordered medium and got well. Also way too much sauce and cheese on top which was cold. Service by May was so so. Disappointed.

We just ate there this past week 2 times while in Bayfield. My husband and I have eaten there 3 years in a row and it has been great every time! This place has the best whitefish we have ever had. We get the fish...and chips and the portions are so huge and it is wonderful! The service is always excellent!More

What a view!! What a cute place! What a fantastic waitress! Just came in for a snack and a drink, but everything was awesome! Abbi our server is fantastic! Ask for her…she’s great! Everyone here is super friendly. Highly recommend!

I ordered the chicken nachos. The nacho toppings were a sloppy mess on top of burned homemade potato chips. The burned potato chips instead of tortilla chips ruined it, but the overall flavor was not good. My husband ordered fish tacos which we always both...enjoy. These were dry and flavorless. Our server was okay, but not super attentive. I noticed that tables around us were getting their salads after their dinners.More

I can't believe all of the people that gave this great reviews. I ordered a beet salad and it came warm! Then the server lied about it (or the cook lied to her) and said that the beets and fennel were sauteed and that's why...it was warm. You would never sautee beets, and these obviously weren't. What I'm sure happened is that they put it under the heat lamp that they use to orders warm until the servers can pick them up and bring them to your table. Then, she asked if I wanted another salad instead. I picked one, but then she came back a few minutes later and asked if I wanted the beet salad, but a cold version of it this time. As if there were two versions. I said I did. It still was not great, but at least edible. I think they should have taken the salad off the bill, but they didn't. My fiancees dish wasn't much better.More

The restaurant was full (a good sign) but there were 2 seats at the bar so we took them. Frank was bartending and was great at his job. Had knowledge about different drinks when we asked and chatted to us the correct amount (some people...ignore or talk too much, not Frank!). We tried the local lemon shandy and a tart cherry cider, both a good choice. We ordered the fish and chips and steak sandwich with slaw to eat. Food was very good. Lots of employees running back and forth. We lucked out with our food choices on this trip to Bayfield. Worth leaving a great tip to someone not only working in the age of many who won't, but also someone good at their job. Thanks!More

We were in a hurry to catch the ferry. Had “loaded potato soup” and roasted beet and blue cheese salad. Both excellent and an excellent combination. Staff honored our timing constraints. Pleasant harbor side location. Good selection of beers.