We noticed that you're using an unsupported browser. The Tripadvisor website may not display properly.We support the following browsers: Windows: Internet Explorer, Mozilla Firefox, Google Chrome. Mac: Safari.
Tripadvisor gives a Travelers’ Choice award to accommodations, attractions and restaurants that consistently earn great reviews from travelers and are ranked within the top 10% of properties on Tripadvisor.
convenient parking..OR a short hike on the Brownstone Trail from the Seagull Bay th Motel. Can be busy during the Summer tourist Season...but any wait is worth the time. During the Pandemic all precautions were observed.
The meals we had at Maggie's were great even though we didn't get to enjoy the funky atmosphere of the dining room because of concerns with covid. The Warm Sicilian pasta with chicken was superb; the chicken so tender, the pasta flavors bright and perfectly...seasoned with tomatoes, basil, feta, red onions, and olives. The fries, served with creamy tarragon sauce and the flamingo tenders were great. The salads large and full of assorted other veggies. The service was extremely gracious and professional ..Minimal packaging, paper containers and no styrofoam. We were here for two days and ate there both days. We'll be back.More
Good food and an interesting selection. I had a whitefish reubin sandwich...SO good!
You can dine in, wear a mask til you get to a table. Order at a window for pick up. I ate outside under their “bigtop” tent across the street.
We had heard of Maggies a couple of years ago and put it on "our bucket list". Well last week 8-13-2020 we made it! We drove from Oak Creek WI to Bayfield WI because we both are flamingo lovers. We got to Bayfield around 10:30...am and they didn't open until 11:00 so we walked down the street to Lake Superior, the beach and surrounding area was beautiful. At 11:00 we went in Maggie's wearing our Flamingo shirts. Told the waitress where we were from and that Maggie's was on our bucket list. Our service was GREAT!!!!! We had the whole hog sandwich and it was incredible!!!!!! Also had the brownie dessert, OMG to die for. Only disappointing moment was that Maggie was not there, we would have loved a picture with her. Maybe next time, because we WILL be back. Oh yeah lots and lots of flamingos, we were in "flamingo heaven'. If ever in the area it is a must go to.More
Dined here on 8/4/20. We ordered our food only to find out after a 30 min. Wait period that they were out of the Whole Hog sandwich, which we understood. My husband then ordered the Flamingo Flatbread. We waited another 20 min. for the rest...of the family’s good Tom one out. The waitress then came out and said they had just put the flatbread in. He waited like an hour and a half to eat and the rest of us were done. The waitress apologized when she first came out about the sandwich but didn’t do anything to make it better for my husband. We respectfully paid the full cost of the meal but we were very unhappy with how they handled things. On a good note the blueberry salad I had was excellent and my daughter’s turkey club was good. Husband and son’s deep fried chicken tenders and flatbread okay.More