We would love to have experienced Manypenny this year, but could not get waited on. We were seated (seat yourself), waited and waited and finally got a glass of water. But that was about it. I could see waitstaff chatting in a group in the...next room, but the room full of diners was being ignored. A couple at a neighboring table who'd been there when we arrived--and had the same experience--got up and left. We soon followed. I realize it's difficult to find workers, let alone good workers, but this experience clearly spoiled our otherwise good impression of Manypenny.More

The food was delicious and I was glad that they were so busy! It took a little while to get our food, but with the help wanted signs, we knew what we were getting into. It was well worth the wait.

Awesome breakfast. Biscuits are fantastic. We have dined in several times but often take it to go and have it our our our sail charter before heading out to tour the Apostles.

Our party of four was quickly seated and taken care of. We all enjoyed our meals, and had fun with our waiter about the Manypenny vs Mannypenny name.

We looked forward to getting here at 11:30 for lunch. They apparently have a policy of delaying lunch when breakfast is busy- no lunch til 12:00. Then we found breakfast is no up to previous standards. Hashbrowns came swimming in oil-not edible-still had to pay...for them. No longer have granola pancakes, my favorite on the menu. Also, took 25 minutes to get our food. Very noisy enviromnent.More

Some of the locals recommended this place for lunch. We were disappointed by the slow service. We ordered the large pizza and it was faster than the other menu items. This made sense for a family of seven adults. It was average quality and service...below average.More

My husband and I had a tasty breakfast here while staying in Bayfield. We enjoyed generous portions and great coffee which the attentive waitstaff kept topped off. We recommend the Eggs Benedict.