This is my second trip to the Fish Market for some fresh Ahi, to grill back at the condo. Good service. The two steaks this time were excellent, some of the best that I've had. I cooked them well but they were also clearly good...cuts. The pricing isn't terribly out of line, but I wouldn't call this place "cheap" either. Fwiw, anyone that knows ahi knows that it isn't a "cheap" item to purchase to begin with (especially if you want decent quality, that is).More

Extremely rude service. Paid 39$ a pound for mani and told cash only on $120. No receipt, very sketchy.

This is one of our favorite places to eat while in Maui. This time was no different. I had the fish plate of the day. (Mahi-mahi). And he had the fish tacos. Best prices on the island and meal.

My kids are picky eaters and even my little one said the shrimp tacos were awesome. Rest of us had baja fish tacos which were also good. We also split a fish of the day plate which was marlin , and enjoyed that along with...the yummy mac saladMore

We were customers a couple of times in November 2022. We ordered the catch of the day specials, fish tacos and shrimp plate. The food was very good, with the exception of the shrimp order. We ordered garlic grilled and we got cajun that were...NOT freshly cooked. They were covered in cajun spice at so tough it was disgusting. But overall you chances of getting a decent meal with catch of the day is guaranteed. The raw fish choices are excellent. The staff that help with the raw fish purchases are excellent; friendly, professional and helpful. This brings me to the most disappointing and unsatisfactory aspect of this establishment. We encountered two different women who worked taking orders on the restaurant side. One was younger and one was older (perhaps mother and daughter?).More

The fish in the fish dinners is thin and badly cooked. A boring selection of poke (compared even to Safeways) and ceviche with much more tomato than fish). It should be easy to find somewhere better.

I ordered from the fish counter pineapple salsa, ocean salad (seaweed and furikakae and...), and fish ceviche. My ordered from the counter a lobster salad sandwich, fish chowder for me. All the food was fresh, delicious and yummy. We are never disappointed at this local...fish market.More

After a long day to watch sunrise at Haleakala, my wife and I wanted a fresh meal where we didn’t break the bank. The Fish Market Maui for that bill. A great full menu to walk up patrons and also a beautifully showcased collection of...fish from the day greeted us. We both had set our eyes on our meals for the evening: me with Two Mahi Mahi Fish Tacos (along with rice and Mac salad) and for my wife the Macadamia encrusted Mahi Mahi with rice and Mac salad). Since seating was limited we carried it back to our condo and ate there. Both dishes were simply amazing. The fish tacos were fresh grilled Mahi Mahi with just a slight bit of spice, and were topped off of with fresh salsas. Amazing! My wife’s Macadamia encrusted Mahi Mahi was perfectly cooked, where the flavors of the fish and macadamia were upfront. A cilantro and sweet chili sauce that came with the dish was a perfect pairing. (I must admit I put the sauce on my fish tacos and I was in culinary heaven!) If you are in Kaanapali and are looking for a fantastic meal…don’t look any further!More

Ordered shrimp fajita plate and 2 fish tacos to go. They were good. I would say the fish needed a salsa. They were served with sliced cabbage and a tomato blend. Fish had a good flavor but needed something to compliment it like a mango...salsa or jalapeño cold slaw. My SO said the Mac salad and rice were good. The shrimp tacos were blackened with onion and peppers sautéed. Came with a sauce which was a little creamy for me. Would have also been good with some salsa, avocado or cheese. All in all I would return to try other items but wasn’t super impressed. Pick up time for to go was on point though. Fast service.More

We often buy fish here to BBQ at the condo. This time, we only had time for take-out fish tacos and I tell you, they are the best! If you love fish tacos, or fresh fish, don’t miss this hidden gem!

Excellent fresh fish tacos! Don't count on eating there - as of August 2022 the only seating is three very small tables outside, and they are always full. But this is a great place for fresh seafood takeout

Overall it’s a ok restaurant for my taste. It’s some outdoor/indoor waiting time, especially on a hot day so embrace yourself while waiting outside. It’s a rather small restaurant, but everyone would find table to seat once complete ordering. For the food part, we had...ono fajitas and Cajun fish which were average, the seafood pasta was much better. Maybe it’s us, I felt this place is overhyped, would be a good one to eat if in the area, I would not drive out of my way to eat there.More