We first went here in 2018 and loved their chicken pot pies. This time, we bought coconut cream and raspberry/peach pie. Just delicious. We were glad to see that after the pandemic, we were able to indulge in some of our favorites.

We tried 3 different pies and several muffins and cookies during our 4 day trip to Maui and all were excellent! Highly recommend.

While an other establishment may have the recognition and location, Maui Pie has the quality. During our recent trip to Maui, we enjoyed pies from multiple locations, but this one was the clear winner for quality and flavor. Give them a try and compare yourself...- you won't be disappointed! Banana Cream perfection!More

Maui Pie has great pies and a large variety. The pies hand made right on the premises. You can and should order specialty pies in advance. They also have very good chicken pot pies that you can take home and bake .

OMG, if you haven't stopped in for this pie, please run there when they open otherwise you will miss out. Took me three tries this visit to finally arrive before they sold out. Yummy

In my search for coconut pies, we came across this bakery. They sold pies by the slice or 6 and 8 inch pies. I chose a slice, and I really liked that it had a regular crust. I would have liked to try their cherry...pie but they were out of it. The selection was limited because of the time we were there. It's evident, that if you are interested in bakery goods, you need to get to these bakeries early in the day. We'll drop by again when we return to the area.More

we knew that maui pie had amazing baked goods and we are always impressed by the variety of flavors but today we were overwhelmed by positive music and some of the best customer service, the cutest girl Ella talked to my family about our stay...on Maui and gave us dinner recommendations and as well as detailed answers to all of our pie questions.More

To settle a family dispute regarding the best pie on Maui, we did a blind tasting of the banana cream, coconut cream and chocolate cream pies from Maui Pie, Leoda’s and Monkeypod. Maui Pie won going away for coconut (though Monkeypod did not have an...entry). For banana cream Monkeypod finished first by a large margin, followed by Leoda’s. For chocolate, tie between Maui Pie and Monkeypod. All were good, though the blind tasting gave Maui Pie a solid showing against tough competition.More

We purchased a chicken pot pie and a sausage quiche. Both were extremely tasty; full of meat. Staff were friendly. Can't eat in - but take these wonderful pies home and reheat.

We picked up pie here twice during our visit to the island. Really one of the best crusts I have ever had. We had pie by the slice and the small cream pies. So delicious even after a day or two in the fridge. We...also got muffins but the pie was the star. Friendly staff, parking lot adjacent. Highly recommend!More

Amazing pies that are delicious. Bought a huge pumpkin pie to eat that was amazing. Apple pies are delicious,

Try the Chocolate Haupia pie. It's like a chocolate coconut merengue. So yummy! My husband had the chocolate peanut butter pie and it was fantastic.