We drive from Kaanapali to Maui Pie, just for the pie. It’s not much of a detour if you are going out from the resort area. Overall, worth the drive Banana pie: excellent Key lime pie: excellent Strawberry rhubarb pie: our new favorite! Chocolate haupia...More

Picked up a coconut cream pie for my family. Holy moly, it's delicious. Not too sweet and the crust is almost a work of art. A 9" pie was about $20, which is more than I'd normally spend, but 1) Maui is just a little...More

Decided to pick up pie for dessert. They didn’t have the cherry pie I wanted, sold out so we got the Mango/Cherry pie. It was delicious.

I had the raspberry and peaches pie by the slice and it was excellent! The balance of the fillings was great. A full pie will give you better value if u have a few people to share your pie with.

Stopped in for an afternoon treat. Got a couple of slices to share of Key Lime and Coconut Cream. Both were very good. Would go again.

Maui Pie is a very excellent spot to pick up a great dinner pie and a dessert pie. Their quality is as high as I've even seen at a pie shop anywhere! Chicken Pot Pie - excellent! Chocolate cream - excellent! Baja cream - excellent!...More

After a long day beaching it we love to get a coconut cream pie, at Maui Pie in Kihei, take it back to the condo and enjoy it for an evening dessert on the lanai. They have a huge selection of dessert pies and meat...More

Got three things: quiche, chocolate cream pie, chicken pot pie. All were great, and not just for Maui. The quiche was so light and tasty! Really great. the others were great, too. What a find!

Love Maui pies, they are the best on the island. But, I fear we might have gotten an overcooked pie (cherry), as the crust was mostly petrified candied filling and we couldn't get pieces out of the pan. Tough when you have guests. Too bad...More

They have wide variety of pies and they are all delicious. If you want to try the local one, the chocolate haupia is sure to delight ( if you like chocolate and coconut). The fruit pies are fabulous as well!