We made a reservation at Oasis by the Beach because it had such great reviews. We even told another couple on our tour group, and they made a reservation too. They went at 5:30pm and she warned me that she did not like her meal....We went at 6:15pm. We were seated after about 10 minutes. We were given water and then we never saw a waiter for 30-45 minutes. No drink orders or meal orders were taken. We tried to make eye contact with anyone who worked there, but no one would even look at us. Finally, we flagged a waiter who half-heartedly apologized for the wait. We wanted to start with calamari, and he told us that he didn't recommend it because it seems to be getting sent back a lot. So, he recommended the clams instead, so we went with that. We ordered a caprese style salad, house salad with an additional piece of ahi (asked for it cooked medium rare), the gnocchi with grilled fresh catch (we were told they were out of the fresh catch and that it would be ahi). We ordered the seared catch, but also had to change it a filet mignon because there was no fresh catch. Our last dish was the braised boneless short rib. The clams, caprese style salad were a good start (also a long wait). The rest of the food was not good. The ahi on both plates were overcooked (past well done), the gnocchi was rubbery and inedible, the short rib and the filet mignon weren't horrible, but certainly not worth the price. Mediocre to inedible was not what we were looking for. The ambiance wasn't what we expected either - not elegant, not with an amazing view. We watched the bartenders flirt with two women all night as we waited for the waiter to ask us how it was or give us the check. It was a long night (2.5-3 hours) to spend with bad service and bad food. There was no shortage of workers - there were food runners and many waiters. We went to 4 islands, went to many restaurants in 12 days and this was the worst meal we had - and one of the most expensive. I think I am being nice by giving it 2 stars instead of 1.More