So bad. I listened to someone at a hotel and decide to give this place a try as I heard it had gotten better since the last time I tried it. More of the same. Bad service. Bad food. Super long wait times for a...place that was not that busy. The pizza barn is very nice looking however that’s all they have going for themselves.More

Staff is so accommodating with take out and food is exceptional we go once a week and have never had a bad experience.

My friend and I stayed in Newcastle for 10 days, for the Archery Antelope season. We were there long enough to try several restaurants in the area, once we discovered the pizza barn we never went anywhere else for dinner. The staff was completely attentive...to our needs and the food was always top notch. We also absolutely loved visiting with Pam. To top it off her Long Island Ice-T‘s were amazing!More

Off the beaten path, many locals and elderly eat there @5pm. The outside of the building has nifty old signs, the inside also has older decor which would be found in an older barn. The menus have a selection for any eater. We has the...salon steak, shrimp scampi, and chicken alfredo. Meals can with salad bar, the chicken sausage soup was very good. Salad was pretty normal for ingredients. The main food had large portions, so come ready to eat a lot. The dinner rolls were great along with the garlic cheese bread. The salmon was cooked to perfection and had a good lemon sauce, the shrimp came in some of the butter/oil it was cooked and topped with, alfredo was a little gritty with the alfredo sauce (probably the parmesan cheese in it) but was still delicious. Staff were attentive and checked multiple times to make sure we were taken care of. If passing through the town definitely consider this restaurant!More

When asked what he wanted to do for his 90th birthday party, our dad decided to have a pizza party. The Pizza Barn was the PERFECT place for his celebration! The party room accommodated four generations of family and many friends. Pam was our hostess/bartender,...and she did a wonderful job. The pizzas were delicious and the room is large, well decorated, and fun for all ages. I highly recommend The Pizza Barn!More

Unique place. Rustic barn setting. Variety of food items. Pizza. Burgers. Steaks. Chicken. Pasta. Service is great. Atmosphere is cool. Prices are very reasonable

Great comfort food! Awesome atmosphere and friendly staff! The best pizza in town and prime rib!! Take the family out!

Great Steaks, pizza, sphaghetti and truly fantastic salad bar with daily made dressing. Service in wonderful and ended the meal with a scoop of ice cream.

Recently went to Newcastle with friends on a hunting trip. We ate here 2 times. Both times the food was good and the service was very good. We noticed a lot of locals were eating here, which tells me it is a good choice.

The food was good, the service was great. This was one of the best small town restaurants I've tried. They offer a huge variety of options so even the picky eaters in your group will find something.

We ate here during our one night stay in Newcastle. Located on the south edge of town you almost feel you're leaving Newcastle) and right across the street from the rail line, Pizza Barn can be found. It is hard to miss with the unique...building design. Food was very good, big portions and a very friendly staff. What more can you ask for. Whether you are by yourself or with kids, this is a place worth visitingMore

Don't let the name fool you. Pizza Barn is the Place to eat in NewCastle! From Pizza to Prime Rib there is something for everyone in the family, The Lasagna is wonderful