The atmosphere is great, upscale without feeling stuffy. The wait staff was top notch, very friendly. Dinesh is about as top notch as a server can be. Very friendly and great customer service. He even gave us complimentary desserts. The food was tasty and plated...well. The Goat Rogan Josh had a lot of bones and wasn't particularly spicy. That's the only downside. The butter chicken, the garlic nan, the rice, and the dessert were very solid. Value of food: quality & quantity were what can be expected at this price point. I would return for the food and will return for the service. Thanks again, Dinesh!More

We had takeout from India Garden. We got 3 different dinners which were tasty. They were similar and all came in unmarked containers. We couldn’t tell the difference between them. We also got the garlic naan bread, which was fabulous.

Love this place love there buffet and my husband love to go for dinner ,coz he love to have seat near fire place with candle light dinner very romantic. staff are very friendly never have any problem , when weather is bad we oder delivery...always on time always good this is the best in townMore

We ordered food couple of times from Indian Garden and first 2 times it was great, after that it started being crap. I once got ras malai that was just legit half a piece in the box and because they knew it was a delivery...through door dash, they tried to trick us, second time my dosa was totally burnt and third time my paneer pakoras were cold and old and all these times my boyfriend ordered it for me so i have to eat to keep his heart but it was a terrible. No more online orders. They suck at it.More

I always love the food, but I have been very disappointed with their online ordering. Multiple times within the past year they have forgotten items on my order. I will no longer eat here as I need to be able to order food for pickup...at lunch. Also, I feel that their buffet is a bit lackluster in variety, but that might be because I have been spoiled by my preferred Indian RestaurantMore

Just enjoyed the Sunday buffet! There's a wide variety of food choices (many vegetarian options and some are even gluten free). The buffet also includes wonderful dessert choices. Everything was fresh, very appetizing looking and, of course, it all tasted great. If you're new to...Indian food, the Sunday buffet is a good way to sample all the intriguing flavors and dishes. The price -- $14.95 -- is right too! The restaurant is quiet and has a friendly, welcoming atmosphere.More

The food was excellent, the waitstaff was knowledgeable, helpful and accommodating. We were there for dinner which is unusual for me as I really like to have a Buffet at an Indian Restaurant as I have a hard time deciding what to order. India Garden...made it easy by having a dinner for two with enough of a choice that I didn't have to decide. The Lamb Curry was excellent as was the Chicken Tikka Marsala. It also included Tandoori Chicken which was very good but for me was overshadowed by the other two dishes. It also included an appetizer of Chicken 65 which was delicious with a touch of heat. It came with Basmati Rice, Nan and dessert. We walked out with a doggie bag. I have already told six or seven friends how good it was. Will be going back to try Buffet soon. This place does a booming business with Take Out, as I watched all the bags leaving the kitchen going past me. Lots of people were having great food that night.More

Fantastic. My girlfriend and I are amateur indian cuisine lovers, and we have been searching for months for an indian restaurant of a bit more class than most. India Garden hit the nail on the head! Every indian restaurant does the white tablecloths and well...dressed servers, but at India Garden I was delightfully surprised to not feel over dressed wearing a button down shirt. The ambiance and atmosphere were delightful. As well, I often feel judged at indian restaurants as a white dude who (truth be told!) doesn't know the culture through and through. I did NOT feel this way at all at India Garden. The staff was very welcoming and judgement free. Drinks- India Garden has a superb selection of Indian beers, and great wine selection. We did not try the lassi although I've heard its great here. Food- We both had chicken tikka masala and cheesy garlic naan (basic, I know). It was all fantastic. The chicken was a bit dry but the tikka masala sauce was great and the naan was as well. The naan could have used more mozzarella but it was still great. I ordered my dish "medium spicy" and my girlfriend asked for hers to not be spicy at all. Overall, we were completely satisfied and hope to return soon.More

This restaurant serves authentic Indian food. They have a very nice lunch buffet spread with 6 deserts on weekends. The range starts from Idly dosa, noodles, veg Pulav, biryani, paneer sabji, daal, 2 punjabi dishes with Nan, Chicken, mutton, etc. Taste and ambience both are...really great. A must visit if you like to have Indian food in Milwaukee.More

Had lunch here today and it was great. Good buffet selection. Loved the eggplant selection; the fish was also very nice. Good hot sauce and onion chutney. Would recommend and I have had Indian food all over the world.... try it you will love it...if Indian food is to your liking!More

This was the first time I’ve ever had Indian food; so a buffet is the best way to try the different dishes (especially when I didn’t know the majority of them). All the food was really good. Place was really busy on Sunday. Service was...very friendly.More

Hands down, this is one of the best Indian restaurants I've eaten at for three key reasons. 1. the service, 2. the quality, 3. the price, and 4. the ambiance. First the servers were all fantastic, well informed, and helpful. The hosts were fun, humorous,...and engaging, even offering to charge our phones themselves. Second, the quality was top notch while prepared in an appropriate amount of time. Third, the price was very reasonable; our group of four had three courses, for $68. Forth, the ambiance was incredibly authentic and relaxing. There were probably 100 individually lit table-candles. Overall, a great experience. I highly recommend.More