On the island riding our motorcycles on this beautiful day. Seen this place was ranked #1 on this site. It was a good stop. Staff is very friendly and the food was great. Meet the owner and she showed us her scooter. Lovely lady. Worth...More

We were near school house beach and was time for lunch. Just down the street stopped in very nicely decorated. I had the special a brat with carmelized onions with horse radish sauce in a baguette Very tasty. Cole slaw on the side with I...More

North side of the island gem. We’ve sat outside and inside for dinner. Gets warm inside quickly. Great atmosphere and lovely food. Small portions, so don’t think your sharing with anyone. Everything is fresh and prepared how you choose. The wait staff was polite and...More

Thought we were going out for a quiet, low key Thursday night. Friends choose Fiddlers Green...We were all blown away.....Absolutely wonderful experience! A world class Jazz band graced us with music you would expect to find in Manhatten. The atmosphere was funky with a boat...More

Saw the ads and looked promising. Problem was it was 3:00 and we could only order from 4-5 choices off the appetizer menu. We were starving and those $5 soft pretzels didn’t do the trick. The mustard that they were served with was excellent though....More

A group of us ate here while on the island for a racing competition. The atmosphere is very down-to-earth with fun décor and memorabilia. On a Thursday night, there was live music that was very fun and entertaining! The food was very good, and though...More

You could drive past this place and think it was perhaps a second hand store. There is the oddest collection of stuff outside and in, and it is right next store to the farm museum, so random pieces are everywhere. The inside is a bar...More

Three years ago this joint was awesome. It was one reason I returned to the island. This year the owner has become unreasonable. There are foolish choices that are made... turning off WiFi for guests. I can't believe there is an attempt to control this...More

Our family with two children stopped here while biking and we are so glad that we didn’t miss it! First of all, the food was so fresh and flavorful—everything was delicious! We tried the caprese & duck breast sandwiches and the kids had pizza. The...More

Eclectic beer and wine selection, friendly staff, live music, funky indoor/outdoor design, fun vibe! I loved this place. Wish I had had dinner here because the food looked really good and the menu options were pretty creative. Note: they don’t serve hard liquor; only beer...More