The Old Fashions are great and they’re inexpensive. Worth the drive just for that. Flat iron steaks are quite good, but not cheap.
1 - 10 of 397 reviews
The food at this restaurant is excellent and it is a beautiful building. On busy nights, it gets so noisy that is is distracting from the experience.
We went for the Friday fish fry. I ordered the senior fish. The baked haddock was overcooked and dry. The 2 very small pieces were smaller fish sticks. Looked like an appetizer. Thank god for potatoes and beans or I would have left hungry. Other...More
This was our second time going here. My son and I had a perfect meal. He had the flat iron steak I had the strip steak. It was awesome. It was served on a cast iron plate. It was warm to the very last bite....More
We got there a little after 5 on a Saturday. Ight, and the joint was jumping. Really busy, but the waitress made us feel like we were her only table. We had the flat iron steaks, and they were perfectly prepared and really tender. We...More
We heard that Cimarolis was famous for its Friday Fish special, its steaks and Old Fashion drinks. We stopped on a Thursday and tried the steaks and the Old Fashions. Both of those were excellent choices and we liked it so much we went back...More
The food was good and the prices are unbeatable. For example, a magnum of wine is $25. It is crowded restaurant during meal times.
It may take a while to get a table, but with$2.50 old fashions and other cheap drink prices it really doesn’t matter. Once seated the food came very quickly and our waitress Robin was awesome!!! The perch was wonderful and my wife had the Friday...More
We were recommended this restaurant by a local tour guide. It’s just short drive outside of Wisconsin Dells, hidden amongst the farm fields. They are know for their Flank Steak and I now know why. It was melt in your mouth delicious and came out...More
Sad to say that I have never had anything other than the flat iron steak smothered with mushrooms & onions with the Italian potatoes. It's not that the menu doesn't look great but that the flat iron is so awesome I just have to have...More