We were in Plum City to stop at the hardware store and saw Mollys on Main. Our lunch was excellent. I had a cup of vegetable beef soup-delicious-and a Reuben sandwich. The rye bread was thick and substantial to hold all of the corned beef and kraut. This was NOT deli sliced corned beef but real corned beef from a brisket. It was so tender. My husband had a burger with fries. He said his burger was cooked to perfection. We had pie too which we rarely do. We were a little disappointed to learn they weren’t homemade but they were good. Digger, our server, was great! He said pumpkin and apple pies will be homemade in the fall-we will definitely be back.

Written July 25, 2023

This review is the subjective opinion of a Tripadvisor member and not of Tripadvisor LLC. Tripadvisor performs checks on reviews as part of our industry-leading trust & safety standards. Read our transparency report to learn more.

Liberty17761951

Cottage Grove43 contributions

Can't find a better breakfast within 50 miles

Oct 2018 • couples

We love going here on a Saturday. Small town place at it's best. Outstanding country-style food, great coffee and the people are really nice. Pretty little town with a spring-fed trout lake across the street. Worth the trip...

Written November 14, 2018

Tiffanie M

South Range11 contributions

Amazing food

Oct 2018 • couples

We went to Molly's, and they had an unnamed dish with vodka sauce and pasta. This was amazing!! Great food, and service.

Written October 9, 2018

HiCarbs

United States7 contributions

Food was good

Jun 2018 • friends

The food was good, the service was okay. Not too happy about the leaky roof over our table but I am sure that is fixed by now.....

Written May 7, 2019

270barbe

4 contributions

They're Great!

Aug 2017 • friends

The food is wonderful. It's a cozy little place that is fun to meet friends there. You never feel rushed. Great food!

Written September 7, 2017

mike l

Fairfax311 contributions

Friendly. Tasty. Repeatable.

Jun 2016 • couples

Stopped in for lunch and left totally satisfied. While the menu is not voluminous, the service and quality of food is wonderful. Friendly staff. Clean. Fair prices. Frequented by locals. Decent beer selections. Delicious fish fry. Simple but good salad bar. Play pool, have a beer, grab a bite to eat, sit a spell. Repeatable. Family friendly. Ample parking.

Written July 6, 2016

Peter P

434 contributions

scrumptious burgers

Jul 2016 • friends

Our foursome showed up on a Sunday around noon to find this small town restaurant / bar moderately busy. The place is divided into two rooms with dining in one and a small bar with pool tables in the other. There’s not much going on in Plum City Wisconsin, but this has to be some of the best of what the town has to offer. While we browsed through the menu we noshed on deep fried cheese curds — fresh ones with no greasy taste. We ended up ordering three burgers and a wrap and all arrived hot and juicy! Perhaps a bit too juicy — the wrap had some kind of sauce and it was actually making the wrap soggy. The burgers were big and juicy too — the hold them in your hand and juice runs down your forearms kind of juicy - but they were delicious! We were way too full for dessert - not even sure what had been on offer because we were way too full to even consider anything else. This is just a small town resto with a limited menu but the food is solid the prices are fair, the service was fast and friendly. Would we re-visit? You betcha! In a heartbeat.

Written July 4, 2016

MARKOWisconsin

Gulfport111 contributions

Great Surprise for our first visit

Mar 2016 • couples

We are from the area, but had not eaten at Molly's on Main. It was a quiet weeknight but we found the place to be charming and clean. Our wait person was prompt and very friendly. Brought our drinks quickly and we had a very tasty dinner. The food was presented well and had great flavor. Most restaurants have very little flavor in their food and even thou it is not bad, it usually does not leave an impression. We will be back this Molly's soon to try another menu selection.

Written March 16, 2016

Showing results 1-8 of 8

Best nearby

We rank these hotels, restaurants, and attractions by balancing reviews from our members with how close they are to this location.

Best nearby hotels

See all

Nugget Lake Campground

4.58 miles away

Best nearby restaurants

See all

Beavs Restaurant and Tavern

0.07 miles away