We got takeout pizza. The staff was very friendly and I was in and out quickly. The pizza is very good and I’m wanting to try other items on the menu.

Got so lucky finding this place! The parking lot was crowded, but they were so organized and all of the employees were so nice! The food was OUTSTANDING. I had a calzone. The thing was massive and the most delicious I have ever had! There...is plenty of seating to accommodate everyone, and there is something on the menu to please everyone. If I lived here, I would eat at this place at least weekly!!More

Food was good. Easy to order online and pickup. The staff there were amazing to watch - super busy and they were seriously busting their butts to get everything done and customers served as quickly as possible, it was impressive.

Absolutely the best! Food, service and prices! We love this restaurant and visited several times on our Williamsburg/Virginia Beach vacation. Food was fresh with over-sized portions. Always busy. You can't go wrong with what you order. We had many sandwiches and tried the pizza as...well. All the Staff is friendly and professional. The take-out is as busy as dining in line. The Best! Highly Recommended!More

When you walk in this place, the line starts at the door, so you know it's got to be good. The menu is huge - all with a NY feel to it, as it should be. We loved our food and the entire experience.

We stopped in here one Sunday afternoon, and had a decent enough meal. The facility was fairly clean (though many tables needed bussing), with a bustling urban deli/diner ambiance. One orders at the front counter (the line can get long at times), finds seating, and...picks up their order once their number is called. We had the Reuben and gyros sandwiches; not the best we've had of either, but fair enough selections overall. We ordered the carrot and chocolate cakes for take-out; and found both to be quite tasty, later that evening. All and all, a decent option, if one has a taste for urban deli offerings.More

I had a cold New York sub. It was delicious and huge! I easily made two meals of it. Unfortunately, I also bought what appeared to be a delicious piece of raspberry cake from the cold case. Both the cake and icing were hard as...a rock and seemed to be quite a few days old. I threw it out after taking a bite. What a shame. I wasted $7.00 on a dessert that should never have been sold had the restaurant quality checked their product.More

In town for the week and ate here twice! The food is always delicious and made fresh. Highly recommend the NY Deli!

This review is more about their service or efficiency than the food. For this style of restaurant (you order at a counter and then pick up your food when your number is called; or you phone in your order and come pay and pick up...your order) the food is good. My "beef" is that I called at 4:45 pm on a recent Friday to inquire as to what time I should call in an order for a cheeseburger and French fries to be picked up at 6:15pm and was told they could take the order and have it ready by 6:15pm. I arrived there at 6:00pm and stood in line and paid for the order. (There is a separate counter for orders that are called in as opposed to walk-ins) Then I stood there and watched as other people came and paid and picked up their order and left. One elderly man said he had called in his order 20 minutes ago and I informed him that he could pay for his order and they would call his name when his order was ready. Well, a few minutes later, he left with his order. At a little after 6:30pm, I heard my name called with my order from back behind the regular counter so I went to pick it up and mentioned that I had been waiting for half an hour and was told that they were busy, not, "sorry for the wait" but a brisk, "we're busy". This review is more to let potential customers know that they may want to go there and place an order rather than call it in as the staff seems to be a bit overwhelmed and curt due to so many phone in orders.More

Wish we had found this place sooner. We would have gone more than once! The sandwiches are authentic and huge. We were able to share. We also enjoyed a side of tater salad and a huge piece of chocolate cake. Definitely a must do on...your trip to Williamsburg!More

Went to the New York Deli for take out. Ordered a cold corned beef on rye with coleslaw a russian dressing, a slice of plain cheese cake and a greek salad with greek dressing. What we received instead was corned beef on rye with lettuce,...tomatoe, cheese and mustard. Cole slaw and russian dressing on the side. NO cheese cake and oil and vinegar instead of greek dressing. Live 30 minutes away, so no way could we return this hot mess to them. Way to ruin dinner, guys.More

we stop in here every time we go to Williamsburg. the sandwiches are so big we usually share. love the reuben and the philly cheese steak. (and the carrot cake and cheese cake) judging from the crowds, lots of folks in Williamsburg must like it...too.More