Pricey but delicious! Go first thing when they open. We went on a Saturday morning and got there 15 min after they open and got their last peach cobbler. It was worth every dime! We also ordered half of the bourbon orange pecan and original...pecan. Both delicious! I was a bit skeptical about the bourbon orange but it really brightens the pie up. The owners were so sweet and friendly. We had some sticker shock but it’s worth the price. Highly recommend! They also have a cute little store selling decor.More

The sign says they are closed in Sunday. However we drove by and saw they were open so of course we went in. I think they were open because of the holiday weekend. Seemed like a lot of shops were open on Sunday because of...the holiday weekend that brings a lot of shoppers. This pie shop is located in a little cute house. Can't find bakeries like these any more. They sell more than pies but the pies are the showcase. We got the pecan, bourbon orange pecan, peach, apple and key lime. I'm not a fan of pecan and fruit pies. I like Apple strudel and we're in a German town so I got the apple pie. Surprisingly it wasn't my favorite of the pies. I love key lime pie and they did not disappoint. It was not too sweet and balanced with sour and sweet. It's one of my favorite pies. I don't like pecan pies. However I LOVE their pecan pie. It wasn't super sweet. It was light. The crust was ... OMG! The pecan is definitely the best I've ever had and the best made here. Good thing I bought half a pie. All the pies were delicious. Bourbon is going to be a unique flavor. Pecan seems to be the pie that makes them stand apart from other pie makers. The peach pie is grown and made in Fredericksburg. Key lime is satisfying. Try them all!More

If heaven had a pie restaurant it would be the Fredericksburg Pie Company. I made the mistake of going to the winery on a Saturday the first time I stopped here about 2PM. Only two pieces of pie left. I can't even remember what I...got that time I was in so much shock. This time we stopped at FPC before going to the winery. Brought my cooler to be prepared. Oh the pie selection dilemma. If you get here early you get you choice of so many great looking home baked pies. On this trip I choose the buttermilk pie and the peach and blueberry pie. The fruit pie had great crust and filling but the buttermilk pie stole the show. Such deep egg custard taste with a perfect crust. I would share a photo but I was so focused on enjoying the pie that I forgot.More

We got there too late in the day to get a big selection, but still wonderful. I had a chocolate covered cherry pie (a special) which was a chocolate cream pie with cherry pie filling on top--delicious! My wife had coconut meringue (meringue mile high!)...and she said it was fantastic with a light meringue. If you want the best selection, go early in the day! But any will be great!More

There were 17 different pie choices (fruit and cream) available when we visited on Thursday at 12:30. We ordered lattice top peach pie and blueberry-peach pie (warming was optional). Both pies had flaky crust and plenty of fruit filling. Store closes when pies are sold...out (usually 2-4pm), so go early for the best selection.More

Chocolate Pie - Pecan Pie - it is all excellent. Get there early though. When they sell out they close

We ordered a blackberry and a pumpkin pie for Thanksgiving. Our guests couldn’t quit raving about how delicious both were but especially the blackberry. Delicious can’t even describe these pies which are worth every penny.