We noticed that you're using an unsupported browser. The TripAdvisor website may not display properly.We support the following browsers: Windows: Internet Explorer, Mozilla Firefox, Google Chrome. Mac: Safari.
The pizza at DiCarlo's is unlike any other in York. First of all it is a rectangular pizza. The dough and ingredients are very good which makes for a tasty treat. If you like peppers try the three pepper pizza. Yum!
You can get the pizza with cold cheese put on right before it's served or you can get melted cheese. I prefer the cold cheese. It just gives it a unique flavor. You can't buy a slice but you can get 3 squares for$4. Very...More
As somewhat of a pizza snob, DiCarlo's does it right! Their crust has the perfect balance of crispy and chewy, their sauce is tasty but not overpowering, and if you get the cheese done in the "original" way (cheese put on the pie after the...More
Would seem like any other pizzeria until you get your pizza. Number 1 is that it's a square pizza like they like to make in Ohio. Makes sense, it fills the box, more pizza for the money? Number two is the cheese is placed cold...More
Stopped at DiCarlos with my family while at my Son's baseball playoff after reviewing trip advisor high reviews. Definitely worth stopping to try this pizza, as it is in the top of any pizza I have tried.
As indicated by another review, it's hard to...More
Wow, I grew eating DiCarlo's in Steubenville, Ohio and Weirton, West Virginia. This is a franchise and they have done a good job with the brand. I had six slices and loved them. Unique way of topping pizza with cold cheese. Love it!!!
DiCarlos pizza in York has an amazing pizza with a few sizes to choose from. You also have the choice of getting your pizza " melty" or they will put the Chee's on after it's done. Great cheesy bread too. Check them out some First...More
The pizza is absolutely delicious (olive blend is my favorite) but the buffalo chicken calzone is literally the best calzone I have ever had, anywhere. Everyone who works there is so kind! And they DELIVER now...!!! What could be better!!!
We ordered a heart shaped pizza and salad for Valentine's Day! That crispy crust with the flavorful sauce and fresh cheese is just over the top! The salad is always fresh with some welcome additions - olives and sweet peppers!
We stopped here a week...More
First off, this pizza is absolutely delicious! I say that mainly because of their pizza sauce and super crispy crust. I don't know if they make their own sauce there, but I am assuming they do based on the fact that it just doesn't taste...More