We noticed that you're using an unsupported browser. The TripAdvisor website may not display properly.We support the following browsers: Windows: Internet Explorer, Mozilla Firefox, Google Chrome. Mac: Safari.
All reviews stuffing pies sweet potato casserole meatloaf eagle hotel portions are huge home cooking coconut cream won't leave hungry wonderful place to eat green beans homemade food street parking prices are reasonable amish noodles erie leftovers
We had several tables all set up by a Christmas tree where we could place our exchange gifts. We also were supplied a table where we were able to do a cookie/candy share. There were four dinner options to choose from, I had the pork...More
I eat there every time I drive through and nobody I’ve taken there have ever had a complaint and keep saying how great everything thing is ..... I ordered 6 pies for thanksgiving and they were awesome , a big hit and I’ll do it...More
My wife and I have passed by the Eagle Hotel, a beautiful Stone building in Waterford Pa. many times on our way home from trips to Erie, Presque Isle. We always assumed it was closed. So, this time we decided to take the short drive...More
I live in Waterford. As much as I love visiting new places and trying new restaurants, I have never found one that can compete with Sugar n Spice. My #1 choice. The atmosphere is nice, service is good, food is excellent, prices are reasonable, and...More
Very good amish-style country homemade everything. Priced quite reasonably.
Portions are quite large. You won't leave hungry, think of it as two meals for the price of one.
Don't think there is any poor choice on the menu, and don't forget to leave room for...More
We went there for our grandson's graduation. The food is AMAZING! I got the Meatloaf and Roast duo with a side of Amish noodles all with gravy and a side salad. OMG! Everything was delicious and the portions are HUGE! I had enough left over...More
My husband and I stopped in for dinner and it was the BEST decision we made on our long weekend get away. We have numerous Amish cooking options near home in Ohio, but we never expected the gem that this restaurant proved to be. The...More
We have been meaning to stop here for years. We're usually on our way back from Erie and have eaten something there. This time we changed things around and were very glad we did. Home cooking. You can't beat it! The prices are reasonable, the...More
My family and I stopped here for dinner and were not disappointed. The food was home cooked and wonderful. The desserts are also homemade and delicious. You certainly will not leave hungry with their large portions. All the employees were were very helpful and attentive...More