We noticed that you're using an unsupported browser. The TripAdvisor website may not display properly.We support the following browsers:
Windows: Internet Explorer, Mozilla Firefox, Google Chrome. Mac: Safari.
TripAdvisor
Stroudsburg
Trips
Inbox
More
    Help Center

    Garlic Prime Steak & Seafood

    Save
    189 reviews
    #4 of 85 Restaurants in Stroudsburg
    $$ - $$$, Italian, American, Steakhouse
    907 Main St, Suite 101, Stroudsburg, PA 18360-1662
    +1 570-476-6555
    Website
    Menu
    Open Now:See all hours
    All photos (53)
    All photos (53)
    Certificate of Excellence
    Reserve a Table
    Sun, 2/17
    8:00 PM
    2

    Ratings and reviews

    4.5 189 reviews
    #4 of 85 Restaurants in Stroudsburg, Pennsylvania
    Certificate of Excellence2015 - 2018 Winner
    RATINGS
    Food
    Service
    Value
    Atmosphere

    Food and ambience

    Local cuisine, Italian, American, Steakhouse, Seafood, Contemporary
    Not a lot of linguine.Filet mignon with Gorganzola sauce was perfectly prepared.
    Special occasions, Romantic, Large groups, Bar scene, Business meetings
    ... would spend, but totally worth it for a special occasion while in town.Romantic and Inviting

    Location and contact

    907 Main St Suite 101, Stroudsburg, PA 18360-1662
    Website
    +1 570-476-6555

    Menu

    SALADS & SOUPS
    Ricotta Salad
    Cherry Heirloom Tomatoes | Fresh Snap Peas | Arugula | Whipped Superfina Ricotta Cheese | White Balsamic Pesto Vinaigrette
    Classic Caesar Salad
    Crispy Romaine | House Made Caesar Dressing | Brioche Croutons Parmesan Cheese
    Wedge Salad
    Bacon | Bleu Cheese Crumbles | Frizzled Onions | Tomato | Cucumber | Port Wine Drizzle | Creamy Bacon Dressing
    Roasted Beet Salad
    Roasted Beets | Goat Cheese | Candied Pecans | Marinated Red Onions | Leafy Greens | Garlic Beet | Balsamic Vinaigrette
    Arugula Salad
    Mandarin Oranges | Feta Cheese | Candied Pecans | Dried Cranberries | Arugula | Poppy Seed Dressing
    Soup Du Jour
    Chef's seasonal creations
    ENHANCEMENTS
    Chicken
    Shrimp
    Scallops
    Eggplant
    Filet
    Lobster Tail
    Salmon
    APPETIZERS & SHARED PLATES
    Ahi Tuna Tartare
    Ahi Tuna | Avocado | Cucumber | Fried Shallots
    Garlíc Short Rib Sliders
    Short Rib | Sautéed Onions | Gruyere Cheese | Cornichon | Petite Brioche Roll
    Lobster Mac & Cheese
    Creamy White Cheddar Cheese | Canadian Lobster | Pasta Shells
    Crab Cakes
    Jumbo Lump Crab | House Tarter Sauce | Green Apple Slaw
    Torched Goat Cheese
    Goat Cheese | Roasted Red Peppers Coulis
    Calamari & Mussels Fra Diavolo
    Calamari | Mussels | Secret Spicy Sauce | Parmesan Crostini
    Bacon Wrapped Scallops
    Sea Scallops | Bacon | Cucumber Relish | Tomato Jam
    Black Jack
    Grilled Filet Mignon Medallions | Gorgonzola Cream | Sauce | Fresh Arugula | Spicy Cherry Pepper Relish | Toasted Crostini Bread
    Sweet Crab
    Jumbo Lump Crab Meat | Jicama Roots | Avocado | Pita | Martini Butters Sauce
    Fried Mozzarella Pinwheel
    Mozzarella | Prosciutto | Roasted Garlic Olive Oil | Seasoned Breadcrumbs | Fresh Basil
    HAND-CUT STEAKS
    Choice of two sides
    Filet Mignon
    Local | Grass-fed; Available in 6 oz. | 8 oz. | 12 oz.
    Rack of Lamb
    New Zealand Rack of Lamb | Mustard Infused Bread Crumbs | Guava Glaze
    Hanger Steak
    10 oz. | Prime | Antibiotic Free | Grass-fed
    New York Strip
    12 oz. | Prime | Creek Stone | Antibiotic Free
    Ribeye
    14 oz. | Prime | Antibiotic Free
    Chef's Signature Steak
    Market Price, Add a Lobster Tail for an additional price
    SIDES
    1 Lb. Baked Potato
    House Made French Fries
    Mashed Potatoes
    Broccolini
    Broiled Brussel Sprouts
    Sautéed Spinach
    Mac & Cheese
    STEAK ENHANCEMENTS
    Signature Garlíc Steak Sauce
    Whipped Herb Butter
    Whisky Cayenne Butter
    Gorgonzola Cream Sauce
    Bordelaise
    Caramelized Onions
    Market Mushrooms
    CLASSIC
    Seafood Garlic
    Scallops | Shrimp | Jumbo Lump Crab | Light Seafood | Crema | Linguini. Pairs well with Pinot Grigio
    Lasagna
    Sausage | Veal | Ground Sirloin | Goat Cheese | Ricotta Cheese | Garlic Shell | Marinara. Pairs well with Sangiovese
    Slow Roasted Chicken
    Half Chicken | Garlic Basil Sauce. Pairs well with Sauvignon Blanc
    Fresh Salmon
    8 oz. Atlantic Salmon Filet | Tomato Basil Cream Sauce. Pairs well with Chardonnay
    SEASONAL
    Eggplant Parmesan Stack
    Breaded Eggplant | Ricotta Cheese Garlic | Marinara | Fresh Mozzarella | Spinach. Pairs well with Merlot
    Blackened Tuna
    Yellow Fin Tuna | Asian Infused Rice | Ginger Teriyaki Sauce. Pairs well with Rosé
    Chicken Parmesan
    Breaded Chicken | House Marinara | Fresh Mozzarella | Linguini. Pairs well with Meritage
    Show full menu

    Details

    Improve this listing
    About
    Garlic Prime Steak & Seafood offers quick lunch service done right and the only upscale evening dining experience in the Poconos. With a lunch menu featuring American classics like burgers, wings and sandwiches and an elegant dinner menu featuring Prime steaks and fresh seafood, there is something for everyone. Garlic proudly boasts the highest quality foods available, the best service around, a full-service bar, live entertainment on weekends, breathtaking patio dining, local art on every wall, and a young, innovative management team.
    Special Diets
    Vegetarian Friendly, Gluten Free Options, Vegan Options
    Meals
    Dinner, Drinks, Late Night
    CUISINES
    Italian, American, Steakhouse, Seafood, Contemporary
    FEATURES
    Takeout, Reservations, Outdoor Seating, Seating, Waitstaff, Television, Highchairs Available, Wheelchair Accessible, Serves Alcohol, Full Bar
    Reviews (189)
    Write a Review
    Filter reviews
    189 results
    Traveler rating
    106
    47
    21
    10
    5
    Traveler type
    Time of year
    LanguageEnglish
    106
    47
    21
    10
    5
    Show reviews that mention
    All reviews seafood steak scallops arugula salad rack of lamb chocolate cake surf and turf creme brulee new york strip plantains baked potato wedges bread chicken our waiter sweet crab great patio
    FilterEnglish
    Updating list...
    1 - 10 of 189 reviews
    Reviewed 5 days ago
    Good but a little pricey

    While I can’t say that anything we had was bad. I also can’t say that anything was great. We went for a birthday celebration and the food was good with a nice selection for everyone but no one was blown away by anything and the...More

    Date of visit: January 2019
    1  Thank Lyoz
    Reviewed January 10, 2019
    First Class

    This restaurant was recommended to the owner of Creative Canvis-just around the corner. They didn't miss one detail. We were promptly greeted and seated-even though we didn't have a reservation. We order appetizers and they were all very creative. Service was excellent.

    Date of visit: January 2019
    1  Thank BoilerDaveNH
    Reviewed December 28, 2018
    High Price for Mediocre Quality

    My Fiancé and I had dinner at Garlic on Christmas Eve. We we're in town for a holiday escape at a bed and breakfast and got excited to get a reservation at what appeared to be one of the best places in town. We we're...More

    Date of visit: December 2018
    1  Thank IanPC87
    Reviewed December 15, 2018 via mobile
    Anniversary Dinner

    We had dinner here to celebrate our 24th anniversary and really enjoyed our meals. My husband had a New York Strip with whipped herb butter which was cooked perfectly, with a baked potato and broccolini on the side. I enjoyed the Seafood Garlic, which had...More

    Date of visit: December 2018
    Thank ParksRCalling
    Reviewed December 11, 2018
    Good place to celebrate a special occcasion

    We went there to celebrate our anniversary. The food is excellent and the service is very attentive. The staff are truly professional. As others have said, be prepared to pay for the experience, but if you are celebrating a memorable occasion, you won't be disappointed....More

    Date of visit: July 2018
    Thank johnnyv316
    Reviewed November 21, 2018
    A gem in Stroudsburg

    My girlfriend and I recently celebrated her birthday at Garlic and were very pleasantly surprised with both the quality of the food and the service we received - it's like going to a fine steakhouse in a big city- but in the beautiful and quaint...More

    Date of visit: November 2018
    Thank BWOspinner
    Reviewed November 18, 2018
    VERY good food, but be prepared to pay

    If money isn't an issue, this place is for you. I had the Seafood Garlic for $34, which was absolutely delicious. It came with exactly 2 scallops, 3 shrimp, and I couldn't find any crabmeat. Not a lot of linguine. Hubby had the 14oz Ribeye...More

    Date of visit: November 2018
    1  Thank CPop819
    Reviewed November 15, 2018 via mobile
    Delicious!

    We were sent here from the holiday inn express by the manager Maurice. Phenomenal recommendation. An amazing ambiance and delicious entrees. We will most certainly when we come back to the area. Thank you Maurice!!

    Date of visit: November 2018
    Thank Wanderer34116336869
    Reviewed October 30, 2018 via mobile
    Seafood and lamb

    Food has excellent flavor. It's very fresh. Food its cooked right Specials are not on the menu and something new. A little on the pricey side but definitely worth every penny. People are so nice and friendly atmosphere great! Samantha was our bartender and about...More

    Date of visit: October 2018
    Thank 609paulu
    Reviewed October 28, 2018 via mobile
    Sophisticated lunch

    Looking for a good hearty lunch we saw good reviews on TA so decided to stop. We were in sweats driving around the poconos on Sat afternoon with the kids. Reception was very pleasant and no one gave us looks for how we were dressed....More

    Date of visit: November 2017
    Thank vzescape
    View more reviews
    123456…19
    Nearby
    Nearby HotelsSee all 8 nearby hotels
    Hampton Inn Stroudsburg / Poconos
    853 reviews
    .21 miles away
    Econo Lodge
    112 reviews
    .41 miles away
    Pocono Plaza Inn
    310 reviews
    .73 miles away
    Holiday Inn Express Stroudsburg - Poconos
    474 reviews
    1.19 miles away
    Nearby RestaurantsSee all 138 nearby restaurants
    Thai Orchid
    232 reviews
    .11 miles away
    Cafe Duet
    62 reviews
    .24 miles away
    Siamsa
    267 reviews
    .26 miles away
    Nearby AttractionsSee all 39 nearby attractions
    The Olde Engine Works
    45 reviews
    .67 miles away
    Sherman Theater
    63 reviews
    .41 miles away
    Banter's Hard Cider
    11 reviews
    .24 miles away
    Pocono Mountains Visitors Center
    24 reviews
    .08 miles away
    See all 8 nearby hotelsSee all 138 nearby restaurantsSee all 39 nearby attractions
    Questions & Answers
    Ask a question
    bran882
    July 12, 2017|
    AnswerShow all 3 answers
    Response from Nick S | Reviewed this property |
    We went on a Saturday night. It was mostly couples. There were a few tables of families. The kids were over 5 years old. and dressed like it was a special occasion. The wait staff was patient and attentive.
    1
    Vote
    CamNJ
    June 19, 2017|
    AnswerShow all 2 answers
    Response from Bossy34 | Reviewed this property |
    Yes indeed
    0
    Votes
    Is This Your TripAdvisor Listing?
    Own or manage this property? Claim your listing for free to respond to reviews, update your profile and much more. Claim Your Listing