The food and the wait staff were spectacular. The flavors of each dish were spot on, and the bar tender made a mean lemon drop martini as well. The waitress was beyond fantastic. She made us feel welcomed and like valued customers. Admittedly, we were...More

We were in the area to celebrate our 40th anniversary.. We had dinner one night and then stopped again for lunch. Comfortable dining area - nicely decorated bar. Also, outside seating available too.

The bed & breakfast we were staying at recommended the Fireside Tavern. We were seated right away and our waitress was good. We started with side salads which were a good size and fresh. My boyfriend ordered a hamburger and I ordered the crab cake...More

I visited the area and spent the night at the Holiday Inn next door. I thought I'd go to Lancaster for one of their nicer restaurants with a friend, but took a look at the reviews for Fireside and they looked good. After a 20...More

We enjoyed drinks and a plate of nachos/chili after a rainy day around Amish country. A nice surprise was a live entertainer-singer/guitar player who was quite talented

PROS: Great friendly service, nice ambiance and decor, BEER selection outstanding and uniquely descriptive...... CONS: the entrees were awful. ......................... Next door to the very dirty Clarion Hotel, this restaurant appeared to be a good choice up until we got our entrees. The steak tasted...More

We were in town for a combination personal/business weekend. My wife and I hit Fireside Tavern for dinner our first night. Oh. My. Lovely, cozy ambience inside, friendly attentive service, great food and drinks. Highly recommended! We enjoyed it so much we brought back a...More

We ate here the night we arrived in Strasburg because it was late, we were tired, and the restaurant was on the same property as the hotel we were staying at. The staff at the hotel recommended it, saying it was really good and very...More

Fireside Tavern consistently serves up a good dinner! Apparently the local people agree, as it is a very popular restaurant and I highly recommend making a reservation on peak periods. No need for an appetizer since entrees come with a generous salad. We ordered one...More

We were in Lancaster to celebrate our 40th anniversary and attend the Sight and Sound Theater. Wanting a nice mean before the show, we called to see if we could get an early dinner reservation. We are so glad they were able to accommodate us....More