We noticed that you're using an unsupported browser. The Tripadvisor website may not display properly.We support the following browsers: Windows: Internet Explorer, Mozilla Firefox, Google Chrome. Mac: Safari.
This place has grown from the standard pizza joint to the unique twist of what folks want in their beloved comfort foods. We look forward to the spontaneous menu that's always delicious and great quality!
This was our first visit here and we will be back. The menu had plenty of choices and we both went with burgers. They were fantastic! We also got a flight of some of the craft beers they have on tap. Always fun to try...new beers. Would love to try the pizza on our next visit. It looked really good as well.More
Review collected in partnership with HP Windows 10
This business uses tools provided by Tripadvisor (or one of its official Review Collection Partners) to encourage and collect guest reviews, including this one.
I live locally and eat here almost once a week. I am amazed of the crowd every night that I don't recognize most folks as most are from out of town. That is how good this food is for little New Carlisle. They have refined...the menu so much everything Ive tried is delicious. The craft beer list is exceptional for a place this size. The Haystack Burger is incomparable in my book to about any other burger in the Midwest Ive tried. Service is quick, efficient and friendly. Parking is a challenge when it gets busy on the weekend; I suggest Tues-Thurs or before 5pm to make it easy. You will enjoy eating here. We had a special this weekend- fried bluegill and fries that was a real treat! we see Lots of families eat here and is kid friendly.More