We ordered a 9 in pizza and smoked bbq sub. The sub was really dry it didn't have much sauce and theme at was really dry. The pizza was hard and overcooked and just bland. We were traveling and like to try something new and...local, but this wasn't a good choice. We definitely won't try this again.More
Travel for work and as stated in other reviews, I like to try local pizza places. I tried to call but no answer, so I ordered online and was hoping for the best. When I pulled up I thought Oh Boy what did I do...?...Well when you walk in it all changes, the phone was ringing off the hook and people were coming in to pick up their food and I realized why the phone is always ringing, they are BUSY! Teafords is one of the best pizzas I have had, it is as good as a local shop back home and maybe even a tick better.😳 I would definitely eat it again and try some of their subs also probably.More
The pizza here seems to keep getting better. I'm not sure how they're pulling that off, but the quality seems to keep improving.
The best pizza ever is the mashed potatoe pizza. I get all my friends to try and they are hooked. it is a must try.
Teaford's has great pizzas and carry out items. It's an original "short stop" store. The owner is friendly and taking over from his dad. Hope it will be there a long time, Aaron!
I used to go to Teaford’s as a child more than once a day living so close by! 50 years later, oh the memories! Aaron Keaser is the amazing owner and will make your visit most memorable! He was not even born when I went...here but he has all of our stories! Nileys, Milo Teaford, penny candy! Great night of memories!More
This is a neighborhood grocery store. Emergency shopping. Also has some emergency food, like Pizza and snacks.
One of the best places in Greenville for pizza. Great prices for the size of the pizza. They load up the toppings. Well worth the time and money
This place has the best pizza in Greenville hands down. You pay a couple extra bucks versus the chain restaurants but its worth it. If you like lots of cheese this is the pizza for you. The spudtacular mashed potato is great.
This is a nice convenient store with a great menu. I haven't ordered anything besides the pizza because it's the best pizza in Greenville! The owners are very friendly too. They have all kinds of drinks, candy, and chips. Stop in and pick up a...menu -- they have a lot to choose from.More
Best pizza in town. Love the corn nuggets too. Crust is perfect, sauce is great, cheese is browned perfectly and they don't skimp on the toppings
Love Teafords pizza. My number one choice in Greenville. Not to keen on the subs I have tried but their corn nuggets are super yummy
Some of the best pizza in town !! Their subs are great as well - they are loaded down with the fixings of your choice. Carry-out beverages and lots of snack items.
Teaford's had the best pizza in town! I absolutely love their pizza the only down side is that they don't deliver.
If I had to rate the best pizza in Greenville, Teafords would probably win. It's a little costly, but it is delicious.