We noticed that you're using an unsupported browser. The Tripadvisor website may not display properly.We support the following browsers: Windows: Internet Explorer, Mozilla Firefox, Google Chrome. Mac: Safari.
All reviews chicken thighs salmon cider donuts arancini burger deviled eggs pudding chowder salad bread fries prime rib company holiday party pitcher of beer the food was absolutely delicious cinnamon sugar salt and pepper
Came here with another couple and had a very nice meal. The service was very good and the salmon was excellent. I tried my wife’s chicken riggies and they were very good as well. Beer and wine selection was very good but I think the...More
I met my son, who goes to Syracuse, for dinner at the Cider Mill. What a nice place to go for dinner. Awesome menu. Great drink choices. Try the deviled eggs and the pork chop. Dinner was a little slow coming out; however, worth the...More
Four of us went during the holidays. The calamari appetizer was perfection, a
little crispy it was delicious. All four of us enjoyed our meals. Salmon, ossa buoco, prime rib and rigatoni. We will definitely will go back. I understand they cater also and we...More
Date of visit: December 2019
TSeels, Owner at The Cider Mill, responded to this reviewResponded January 11, 2020
Thank you for your compliments. We look forward to seeing you again soon.
Our sister company, Diamond Catering, excels at creating delicious, unique and memorable receptions. Call soon as we book quickly.
Last week we entertained 65 people for our company holiday party. The food was absolutely delicious and the room was set up perfectly. Appetizers were presented beautifully and tasted great. We had our guests pre choose their selections so the food came out timely and...More
Very nice restaurant. Had the fish so nice they named it twice, Mahi Mahi. Was not a fan of the sauce however the fish was tender. Cup of chowder was very good and big. Filled me up before main course. The cider doughnuts were exceptional....More
Thoroughly enjoyed our dinner there. Our waiter was very friendly and knowledgeable and really added to the whole experience. The menu is a bit progressive but our waiter explained everything and we were very happy with our choices. Hot homemade apple cider donuts were a...More
We had heard great things and it lived up to the reputation.
The atmosphere was charming and cozy. The service was excellent.
The food was perfect. We started with a fall arrinchini which was crisp on the outside and chewy on the inside. The applesauce...More
We had chicken riggies, good sauce, chicken was cooked perfectly, spicy, but not too much. Zuppa de pesce, excellent, loaded with fish and shrimp, the broth was just right and chicken thighs with smoked gouda macaroni and cheese, good, too much cinnamon on chicken. This...More
Went here on a Wednesday night. They were busy, but not like there was a line out the door or anything. Service was really slow, my impression it was not the wait staff’s fault, but the kitchen and bar. I honestly felt bad for our...More