Always a great meal at Southold fish. Always fresh, with a really great menu and relaxing atmosphere.
1 - 10 of 149 reviews
This place has everything, a vast selection of local seafood. Went here two years ago and went back twice during our holiday this year.
We came out to Greenport and decided this place sounded great for lunch. As far as the food goes it was excellent! I had the shrimp tacos and my grandma had the fish tacos with mahi mahi. The shrimp were flavorful and the avocado dressing...More
My wife wanted to end the summer with a lobster roll and glass of chardonnay so I did my research and figured we’d go to the highly rated Southold Fish Market. The lobster roll was large and stuffed, but the lobster chunks seemed tough and...More
We went to get an early Saturday dinner and were told the wait for food was at least an hour. We weren’t prepared to wait so we bought mussels, clams and shrimp and did our own bbq. Excellent seafood. Went back on a Wednesday for...More
I walked in here to have some fresh seafood. Although I was annoyed that I was the only person that received my plates separately, the food was good. I ordered calamari and a lobster roll. I got the calamari first, which was for my gf,...More
Did I mention the fish is fresh? How much fresher than having long islands version of a lobster pound. Fish market on one side the next is a self serve restaurant. Busy during the summer and you have to be patient because everything made is...More
This is one of the best fish markets ever! The restaurant is good for fried clams, fried flounder, a lobster roll and other seaside eats but is best for buying their fresh, local fish. The soups, cole slaw and potato salad are good go-to items...More
A real gem of the eastern Northern folk, great food, great beer, nice, laid-back mood, you should make this a must stop on your way out east.
We have frequented the market many times. Love to have a nice lunch out at picnic tables (love their shrimp tacos), take shrimp cocktail, soup, baked clams home for a quick meal or to take some lovely fresh fish home for dinner. Can’t go wrong...More