Started with flat diet soda and flat seltzer in my cocktail. Wilted salad, chili 99% kidney beans and no flavor. Waitress was not familiar with ingredients of items . Terrible mixed veggies on dinner entree.
Are the prices at this restaurant mid-range / moderate?
Is this restaurant good for bar scene?
Does this restaurant have tables with seating?
Is this an American restaurant?
Is this a pub?
Does this restaurant have waiters and waitresses?
Does this restaurant serve Bar / Pub food?
Does this restaurant serve alcohol?
Is this restaurant wheelchair accessible?
Is this restaurant good for dining on a budget?
Thanks for helping!Share another experience before you go.
this is one of those places that the locals know and keep as a secret. Everything is pretty darn good on the menu. Want to play it safe, get a burger, wow! Try the Shepards Pie if you want to live on the edge, all is sure to please. They have cheese and bread on the table that is sure... More
This is my second bad experience for lunch. I ordered a med/rare burger which came out raw and bloody. The french fries over cooked and my husbands onion rings greasy. The waitress didnt even come back to ask "how is everything".? Very disappointed! The pricing increased too. Suggestion to readers, go to Diggers Irish Pub in Riverhead or Argyle Pub... More
Very good foods and drinks, nice places with friends. Very good servers and friendly. This places has been here for so many years. Great variety menu to choose from. Enough to doggie bag! I have a veal special, they are so yummy! The place is small, try to go for a early dinner with friends, otherwise will be long wait... More
Best hamburgers in town. Everything on the menu is great but the hamburgers are juicy and cooked to perfection. The waitresses are friendly and spot on for service.
Went here last nite with a girlfriend for a girls nite out.we ordered salad with grilled chicken, and she had salad with shrimp. The food was ok, but I think the burger would have been a better option. They looked great coming out of the kitchen. Our waitress was extremely attentive, and she gave us excellent service. I had a... More
Old Street is a great option if you are in the mood for a good burger. Salads are very good too. Service can be inconsistent. Wait staff seems to disappear once you've been served your meal. Seating area in the back of the bar side is casual and nice. Restaurant side dining area seems a bit dated in its decor.
Often when we travel outside the Long Island/NYC area we comment about the fact that the food isn't always as good and we take chances when we pull into an unfamiliar, local restaurant. Sadly, although that is what it felt like today, we were still in NY and in a town where I would expect to get decent food. There... More
Burgers and salads are usually very good. We like to sit in a booth in the bar area for lunch or dinner as dining room seems a bit dated. Service is usually good but sometimes wait staff seems to disappear if the dining room isn't very crowded.
Own or manage this property? Claim your listing for free to respond to reviews, update your profile and much more.Claim Your Listing