We noticed that you're using an unsupported browser. The TripAdvisor website may not display properly.
We support the following browsers:
Windows: Internet Explorer, Mozilla Firefox, Google Chrome. Mac: Safari.
$25 Amazon.com Gift Card Get yours when you book a hotel on TripAdvisor and review your stay!

Sweet Tomato's

$$
Map
Satellite
Map updates are paused. Zoom in to see updated info.
Reset zoom
Updating Map...
Get directions
15 Grand Ave, Shelter Island Heights, Shelter Island, NY 11965-2000
631-749-4114
Monday
Closed
Hours:
Sun 12:00 pm - 10:00 pm
Wed - Fri 5:00 pm - 10:30 pm
Sat 11:00 am - 10:30 pm
More Info
Add Photo Write a Review

171 Reviews from our TripAdvisor Community

Traveler rating
Traveler type
Time of year
Language
Showing 167: English reviews
Level Contributor
14 reviews
11 restaurant reviews
common_n_restaurant_reviews_1bd8 13 helpful votes
3 of 5 stars Reviewed 1 week ago via mobile

This was our first visit in about three years. Service was spotty and the waitstaff seemed hurried. Food was slow to come out of the kitchen. My arugula salad was tasteless-- it was advertised as lemon oil and Parmesan but there was almost no Parmesan or dressing. I would have asked for salt and pepper but waiter was impossible to... More 

Helpful?
Thank GretaBeth
Long Island, New York
Level Contributor
82 reviews
41 restaurant reviews
common_n_restaurant_reviews_1bd8 31 helpful votes
5 of 5 stars Reviewed 1 week ago

My wife and I went to Sweet Tomato on the first Sat after Labor Day for lunch. It was empty, as were all the other restaurants we passed. We had a light lunch and some wine, which were both wonderful. We were served by Igli, who we had a great time with. We would definitely go again.

Helpful?
Thank John C
Wayland, Massachusetts
2 reviews
5 of 5 stars Reviewed 1 week ago

Everything we ordered was wonderful, and we would definitely return. Yes, a bit pricey, but not overly so for the area. I forgot to check to see if the tip was already included in the bill - we tip 20% anyway, but I should have checked........

Helpful?
Thank 2518Mary
Punta del Este, Uruguay
Level Contributor
20 reviews
18 restaurant reviews
common_n_restaurant_reviews_1bd8 4 helpful votes
4 of 5 stars Reviewed 1 week ago

And the only ones practically open on Tuesdays off-season! Delicious oven baked dishes, excellent tomato-mozzarella salad.

Helpful?
Thank Margarita P
New York City, New York
2 reviews
5 of 5 stars Reviewed 3 weeks ago

This was our favorite place in Shelter Island. Great food, staff and ambiance. Get a seat on the front porch if you can.

Helpful?
Thank dollysgirl2016
Level Contributor
5 reviews
5 restaurant reviews
2 of 5 stars Reviewed 4 weeks ago via mobile

Setting is nice but the food is bland and they charged automatically a 20% tip for 3 people in the bill. Not done! I suggest to avoid this place and go somewhere else.

Helpful?
Thank Peter S
Boston, Massachusetts
Level Contributor
4 reviews
common_n_restaurant_reviews_1bd8 5 helpful votes
5 of 5 stars Reviewed 5 weeks ago via mobile

My husband and I just had yet another amazing meal at Sweet Tomatoes. We've had dinner there three years in a row and each has been lovely. The food is delicious, the setting classically beautiful, and the staff accommodating and attentive without being overbearing. Our dinners here are really something we look forward too on our annual vacations on Shelter.

Helpful?
Thank TGBoston
Level Contributor
7 reviews
common_n_restaurant_reviews_1bd8 3 helpful votes
5 of 5 stars Reviewed August 19, 2016 via mobile

Delicious and authentic Italian food. Very good service. Very pleasant to have diner on the terrace. We strongly recommend this place

Helpful?
Thank Valérie j
Sydney, Australia
Level Contributor
114 reviews
62 restaurant reviews
common_n_restaurant_reviews_1bd8 127 helpful votes
4 of 5 stars Reviewed August 9, 2016

This was recommended by our B & B host. It was very busy so we could only get an early sitting. The service was spot on. The ambience was very pleasant. We ordered the seafood stew (that wasn't the name, but I can't remember it) & shared an appetiser as well. It ended up being quite an expensive meal &... More 

Helpful?
Thank peegeeSydney
New York
Level Contributor
5 reviews
4 restaurant reviews
common_n_restaurant_reviews_1bd8 3 helpful votes
5 of 5 stars Reviewed August 3, 2016 via mobile

Amazing dinner. The food was fresh and the service was great. Very comfortable. The staff goes out of their way so you enjoy your meal.

Helpful?
Thank loveleeof2

Travelers who viewed Sweet Tomato's also viewed

Shelter Island, Hamptons
Shelter Island, Hamptons
 
Shelter Island, Hamptons
 
Shelter Island, Hamptons
Shelter Island, Hamptons
 

Been to Sweet Tomato's? Share your experiences!

Write a Review Add Photos & Videos

Is This Your TripAdvisor Listing?

Own or manage this property? Claim your listing for free to respond to reviews, update your profile and much more.

Claim Your Listing
Improve this listing

Restaurant Details

Rating summary
  • Food
    4 of 5 stars
    Service
    4 of 5 stars
  • Value
    3.5 of 5 stars
    Atmosphere
    4 of 5 stars
Average prices
$7 - $32
Cuisine
Italian
Meals
Dinner, Late Night
Restaurant features
Seating, Waitstaff, Full Bar, Reservations, Serves Alcohol
Good for
Romantic, Families with children
Open Hours
Sunday
12:00 pm - 10:00 pm
Wednesday
5:00 pm - 10:30 pm
Thursday
5:00 pm - 10:30 pm
Friday
5:00 pm - 10:30 pm
Saturday
11:00 am - 10:30 pm
Location and Contact Information
  • Address: 15 Grand Ave, Shelter Island Heights, Shelter Island, NY 11965-2000
  • Location: United States  >  New York (NY)  >  Long Island  >  Hamptons  >  Shelter Island
  • Phone Number: 631-749-4114

Questions & Answers

Here's what previous visitors have asked, with answers from representatives of Sweet Tomato's and other visitors
1 question
Ask a question
Middletown, New York
5 months ago

See all questions (1)

Questions? Get answers from Sweet Tomato's staff and past visitors.
Posting guidelines
Typical questions asked:
  • Do you have gluten-free options?
  • Is there a dress code?
  • Do you allow dogs on the outdoor patio?