We noticed that you're using an unsupported browser. The TripAdvisor website may not display properly.We support the following browsers:
Windows: Internet Explorer, Mozilla Firefox, Google Chrome. Mac: Safari.

American Cheese


Ratings and reviews



Special Diets
Vegetarian Friendly
Lunch, Dinner
View all details
meals, features

Location and contact

Reviews (37)
Filter reviews
36 results
Traveler rating
Traveler type
Time of year
Show reviews that mention
All reviews fondue panini potato chips cheese plate nice atmosphere fig beers pickiest eater server meats chef
Updating list...
1 - 10 of 36 reviews
Reviewed January 26, 2019 via mobile

Stopped in to pick up 3 cheeses and go home at 830pm on a Saturday... Not to dine in. Went to the back counter to get said cheese and the server w/ short blond hair in a bob/pixie cut ‘helped’ us. She sighed and seemed...More

Date of visit: January 2019
Thank Samantha V
Reviewed January 5, 2019 via mobile

Great service, Julia. Any restaurant that has all four customers at table using the word “delicious”, is a five star stop. Even satisfied the pickiest of eater for lunch with the mozzarella-red pepper-tomato balsamic fig dressing panini. Look forward to a return to explore more...More

Date of visit: January 2019
Thank Terry D
Reviewed July 3, 2018 via mobile

Dined here with 2 friends. Lovely place. Small bar inside. Food was delicious. We ordered several small plates and shared. My only issue was the chairs. They were cool and industrial looking, but extremely uncomfortable. Towards the end of our meal, I had to stand.

Date of visit: November 2017
Thank portlucayaprincess
Reviewed April 24, 2018 via mobile

Today we went to American Cheese restaurant in Sayville, to have lunch with my Brother and Sister, we heard about the restaurant because my brother George works across the street at Brinkmann Hardware. The restaurant is very cozy and clean, with many types of Cheeses...More

Date of visit: April 2018
Thank nyalbanychef4
Reviewed April 15, 2018 via mobile

Delicious onion soup and panini This small cheese shop and bistro is a hidden gem The menu is quite unique The disposable cutlery is made of wood Great experience

Date of visit: April 2018
Thank 801vickis
Reviewed December 21, 2017

we went over to American Cheese one afternoon for some wine and cheese. We had a bottle of decent wine and one of the cheese plates that they offered on the menu. It came to $100! Really, for wine and cheese? We've been to other...More

Date of visit: October 2017
Thank janlamb48
Reviewed December 6, 2017

Was hoping to try the crepes on a Sunday, but they were not serving them because of a special event going on. Tried the Swiss fondue instead and it was only okay. The texture was too grainy, compared to say, the Melting Pot where their...More

Date of visit: December 2017
Thank DebiOco
Reviewed March 14, 2017 via mobile

We've been to American Cheese through their transition from the beginnings at the farmers market to the small shop on main to the present and fantastic location on Railroad. They've been on Railroad for almost what seems like 3 years and they have been rock...More

Date of visit: March 2017
Thank Steve T
Reviewed February 13, 2017

Such great small plate menu. Amazing bellinis. get a cheese platter for your next party. its pricey but the cheese is the BEST around without question.

Date of visit: September 2016
1  Thank Brieflyjo
Reviewed December 26, 2016

Delicious cheese ... at $26.00/lb. it had better be!!! But what a nice treat for the holidays! Really cool decor, laid back atmosphere, hip staff. Every cute little town needs one of these places. Looking forward to returning, perhaps to eat and sip a glass...More

Date of visit: December 2016
1  Thank MommaRexx
View more reviews
Nearby HotelsSee all 3 nearby hotels
Land's End Motel
19 reviews
1.26 miles away
La Quinta by Wyndham Islip - MacArthur Airport
782 reviews
2.78 miles away
Clarion Hotel & Conference Center
298 reviews
3.41 miles away
Hilton Garden Inn Islip/MacArthur Airport
1,099 reviews
3.85 miles away
Nearby RestaurantsSee all 61 nearby restaurants
166 reviews
.32 miles away
94 reviews
.32 miles away
Cafe Joelle
115 reviews
.28 miles away
Americano Pie Bar Restaurant
27 reviews
.33 miles away
Nearby AttractionsSee all 10 nearby attractions
Saiville Ferry Service
7 reviews
1.07 miles away
Long Island Maritime Museum
67 reviews
1.28 miles away
Country Junque
11 reviews
1.81 miles away
CM Performing Arts Center
18 reviews
1.87 miles away
Questions & Answers
Get quick answers from American Cheese staff and past visitors.
Note: your question will be posted publicly on the Questions & Answers page.
Posting guidelines
Is This Your Listing?
Own or manage this property? Claim your listing for free to respond to reviews, update your profile and much more.
Claim Your Free Listing