We noticed that you're using an unsupported browser. The Tripadvisor website may not display properly.We support the following browsers:
Windows: Internet Explorer, Mozilla Firefox, Google Chrome. Mac: Safari.
Reserve a Table
2
Fri, 7/10
8:00 PM

Ratings and reviews

Certificate of Excellence2016 - 2019 Winner
RATINGS
Food
Service
Value
Atmosphere

Mentioned in

Food and ambience

Local cuisine, American, Seafood, Vegetarian Friendly, Gluten Free Options

Menu

LUNCHEON​
Noon until four o’clock menu
Soupe Du Jour
$11.00
Soupe a L’Oignon Gratinee
$12.00
Duck & Chicken Liver Terrine Aux Truffes
$16.00
Bison Carpaccio w/ Shaved Parmesan
$17.00
Gardiner's Bay Clams on Half-Shell
$15.00
Howard Pickerell's (Eight) Excellent Hog's Neck Oysters
$18.00
Five-Count Jumbo Shrimp Cocktail
$19.00
Smoked Rainbow Trout w/ Fresh Horseradish Sauce
$18.00
PETROSSIAN SUSTAINABLE CALIFORNIA CAVIAR *​
Royal (Sevruga-Grade)
$90.00
Imperial (Ossetra-Grade)
$110.00
Plateau De Fruits De Mer Per Person
$38.00
Plateau De Mer Deluxe
$150.00
Mixed Greens of the Day
Aged sherry vinaigrette or citrus-herb dressing
$13.00
Grilled Shrimps & Avocado Salad
Butterflied shrimp, sliced avocado on petite lettuces, balsamic vinaigrette
$19.00
The Vineyard Salad
Sliced chicken, grapes, dried cherries, toasted walnuts, crumbled blue cheese
$18.00
Spinach Salad
Champignons saute & lardons, dijonnais
$17.00
Chicken & Shrimp Cobb Salad
With bacon, avocado, cucumber, tomato, poached pear
$20.00
New York Deli-Style Roast Beef Sandwich
$17.00
SATURDAY & SUNDAY AND HOLIDAYS​
Canadian Bacon Eggs Benedict Sauce Hollandaise
$19.00
Smoked Salmon Eggs Benedict
$19.00
Brioche French Toast w/ Grade “a” Amber Maple Syrup
$17.00
DINNER MENU​
Lobster Bisque
$18.00
Soupe a L’Oignon Gratinee
$12.00
Duck & Chicken Liver Terrine Au Truffe
$16.00
Foie Gras Saute Porto Blanca
$28.00
Bison Carpaccio w/ Shaved Parmesan
$17.00
Gardiner's Bay (8) Littlenecks on Half-Shell
$15.00
Howard Pickerell's (8) Excellent Hog's Neck Oysters
$18.00
By the Dozen Clams
$20.00
And oysters $25.00
5-Count Jumbo Shrimp, Cocktail Sauce, Citrus Mayonnaise
$19.00
Smoked Rainbow Trout, Fresh Horseradish Sauce
$17.00
GAME, FOWL & MEATS​
Savory Breast of Organic Free-Range Chicken
$31.00
Local Peking Duckling a La Bigarade, Wild Rice
$30.00
Carre D’Agneau Printiniere – Rack of Australian Lamb
$44.00
Grilled Veal Sweetbreads a La Florentine
$36.00
Roast California Pigeon w/ Spring Peas ‘a La Francaise
$38.00
Filet Mignon Maitre D’Hotel 6-Ounce 29 8-Ounce
$39.00
Grilled Dry Aged Sirloin Au Poivre
$42.00
Tournedos w/ Morel & Madeira Sauce
$40.00
DESSERTS MENU​
Apple Tart
Warm puff pastry, vanilla ice cream, caramel sauce
$15.00
Reine De Saba
Valrhona​ chocolate torte, chantilly cream, mixed seasonal berries
$12.00
New York Style Lemon Cheesecake
$13.00
Ile Flottante
Crème anglaise & poached meringue
$12.00
Banana Foster
Bananas,​ puff pastry, vanilla ice cream, carmelized sugar, crème de cacao & dark rum
$15.00
Creme Brulee
$12.00
Macadamia Tart
Roasted whole macadamia nuts, honey praline sauce, white chocolate, chantillly cream, local berries
$12.00
Strawberry Shortcake
$12.00
Fruits
Variety of seasonal, local fruits
$13.00
Ice Cream
Chocolate, vanilla, espresso-coffee
$13.00
Assorted Cheeses
For one
$13.00
Assorted Cheeses
For two
$19.00
Daily Sorbet
$12.00
All desserts are made daily on premises
SAUTERNES BY THE GLASS​
Chateau Petite-Vedrines 2007
$20.00
SPIRITS​
Armagnac
Loubere reserve
$18.00
Ravignan 1979
$35.00
Cognac
Ragnaud 50 year old
$75.00
Hennessey VSOP
$18.00
Calvados
Chateau de breuil 15 year old
$20.00
Grappa
Comb organic white honey & wheat eaux de vie new york distilled
$12.00
Montanaro Barolo Grappa
$18.50
PRICE RANGE
$33 - $73
Special Diets
Vegetarian Friendly, Gluten Free Options
Meals
Lunch, Dinner, Brunch
CUISINES
American, Seafood
FEATURES
Reservations, Outdoor Seating, Seating, Serves Alcohol, Full Bar, Table Service, Wheelchair Accessible
Reviews (338)
Filter reviews
328 results
Traveler rating
178
88
38
16
8
Traveler type
Time of year
LanguageEnglish
More languages
Traveler rating
178
88
38
16
8
Show reviews that mention
All reviews duck steak clams crab cakes historic building old school wine list our waiter romantic dinner fine dining in season the wait staff outdoor seating porch roses fireplace southampton
Selected filters
FilterEnglish
Updating list...
Reviewed March 5, 2020

New York City is the foremost center of the world cultural prouction. Books, plays, movies, ballet, art, sculpture all centers among the NYC literati. As these artists age they tend to migrate to the east end of Long Island, 100 miles east of the Big...More

Date of visit: March 2020
Helpful?
Reviewed February 11, 2020 via mobile

Lovely atmosphere with great menu and fantastic prices Difficult to get seating but worth the wait. Outdoor seating makes the visit worthwhile

Date of visit: October 2019
Helpful?
Reviewed January 12, 2020 via mobile

Loved HOTEL, FOOD, TOWN and SHOPPING. Even Happy Feet was delightful. Only draw back was check in person at FRONT desk. She was Rude and only concerned with how SHE looked!!

Date of visit: January 2020
Helpful?
Reviewed January 7, 2020

This beautiful historic setting serves some of the best food in the Hamptons. A great restaurant for all seasons.

Date of visit: January 2020
Helpful?
Reviewed November 6, 2019

Stayed in Montauk in late October to do some fishing. We forgot to make a reservation for Saturday night. Montauk is busy that time of year so we ended up driving 35 minutes to the beautiful town of Sag Harbor and ate at American Hotel....More

Date of visit: October 2019
Helpful?
Reviewed October 26, 2019 via mobile

After ending our Eastern Long Island day trip we decided to have a late lunch in Sag Harbor. Our friends had never eaten at the Hotel so we told them they had to try it. From the duck sandwiches to the delicious desserts, every thing...More

Date of visit: October 2019
Helpful?
Reviewed October 13, 2019

We were having a lovely dinner until we were rudely interrupted by a roach climbing across a door next to our table. When we advised the manager, he seemed uninterested. Our waiter finally removed the insect.More

Date of visit: October 2019
Helpful?
tayloratthehotel, Public Relations Manager at The American Hotel, responded to this reviewResponded October 29, 2019

And Sharon, we hate to hear it! We are so sorry to hear that your experience was less than exemplary. Sadly, while we do everything we can to keep uninvited guests from joining your dinner-- especially in the colder months, between various purveyors and opening...More

Reviewed October 13, 2019

Since it was the weekend of the Hampton Film Festival, the town was even more crowded, but we managed to get a reservation for 10 next to tables of eight and six, respectively. I've eaten there many times over the past thirty-five years, but I...More

Date of visit: October 2019
Helpful?
Reviewed October 8, 2019

We recently went to the Sag Harbor area for a wedding. A friend recommended the American Hotel bar as a "must" for at least one meal. It was actually our first meal in town. We were late due to traffic. Very late. Yet they could...More

Date of visit: October 2019
Helpful?
Reviewed October 1, 2019 via mobile

This place is worth every penny. My mouth still waters when I think about the crab cake! Delish!! We have vacationed here 2 years in a row and we eat here at least twice during our visits. It’s a must

Date of visit: September 2019
Helpful?
View more reviews
Best nearby
Best nearby hotelsSee all
The American Hotel
136 reviews
.01 miles away
Baron's Cove
335 reviews
.27 miles away
Sag Harbor Inn
148 reviews
.35 miles away
Cozy Cottages
38 reviews
4.40 miles away
Best nearby restaurantsSee all
Page at 63 Main
314 reviews
.01 miles away
Dockside Bar & Grill
252 reviews
.15 miles away
Lulu Kitchen & Bar
111 reviews
.07 miles away
Best nearby attractionsSee all
Bay Street Theater & Sag Harbor Center for the Arts
76 reviews
.11 miles away
Sag Harbor Whaling and Historical Museum
65 reviews
.25 miles away
Sag Harbor Marine Park
26 reviews
.30 miles away
Custom House Museum
12 reviews
.21 miles away
Questions & Answers
Ask a question
kujtimshabani
March 27, 2018|
AnswerShow all 2 answers
Response from Christopher P | Reviewed this property |
Trip Advisor will not let me include what they consider to be an HTML or website link in my answer (which it did not), so I hope you can interpret this email address as I have to write it to you: julian at the american... More
0
Votes
lotus444
August 28, 2016|
Answer
Response from Ray_Susen | Reviewed this property |
Five of us went smart casual two nights ago e.g. Smart casual shorts, collared shirts and nice flip flops for the men.
1
Vote
NoelCopp
August 24, 2016|
AnswerShow all 5 answers
Response from Sebmg | Reviewed this property |
Call us...best way
2
Votes
Google Translation
Is This Your Listing?
Own or manage this property? Claim your listing for free to respond to reviews, update your profile and much more.
Claim Your Free Listing