We noticed that you're using an unsupported browser. The Tripadvisor website may not display properly.We support the following browsers:
Windows: Internet Explorer, Mozilla Firefox, Google Chrome. Mac: Safari.


Italian, Pizza
Special Diets
Vegetarian Friendly
Dinner, Lunch
View all details
meals, features
Reviews (59)
Filter reviews
59 results
Traveler rating
Traveler type
Time of year
Traveler rating
See what travelers are saying:
Selected filters
Updating list...
Reviewed May 12, 2021

Awesome food their calzone's are really good and huge! They also have chicken Riggies that are always great.

Date of visit: May 2021
Reviewed August 24, 2020

We wanted to order aPizza and wings to take back to the campground and we saw this place on line. When I picked up the order the staff was very kind .The food was very good and we will return next year. You can't go...wrong with there food and service. I would highly recommend it.More

Date of visit: August 2020
Reviewed August 21, 2019

Surly counter girl with attitude took our order... clueless waiter brought food to table with no utensils... 6 large fans in small dining room could not be turned off on a cold, rainy day...dining area was much too dark... Limited diet beverage selection (Diet Pepsi...only)...This place changed ownership a couple of years back, and has gone downhill, all while prices have gone UP... $54 for extra large pizza, 3 toppings, 20 wings, and 3 drinks... On the bright side, food was good.... Service, ambiance, and prices were not... Will not return...I pray the original Joe and his mother return..!More

Date of visit: August 2019
Reviewed July 20, 2019

We were staying on Canadarago Lake while our kids played ball at Dreams Park in Cooperstown. We ordered carryout twice from New York Pizzeria and we loved it. We had the meat lovers and it was loaded and well cooked. We also ordered garlic knots,...Chicken Caesar and antipasta salad. If you are staying nearby and looking for a quick bite or some carryout, I give this place two thumbs up.More

Date of visit: July 2019
Reviewed June 23, 2019

Grew up in RS and since we live in the south when we visit, we like to have pizza. What once was a pretty decent pie is now mediocre. I believe it has changed ownership and that makes sense because when I went in to...retrieve our pizza order right after they opened at 11, the guy who greeted me seemed annoyed that he had to wait on a customer so early in the day. The pizza was scant of the three toppings (mushrooms, pineapple and broccoli) as we could hardly taste them and our "well done" was essentially black on the bottom. Too bad to see in a town that is dwindling in many aspects, the pizza is falling short on expectation as well. Addio!More

Date of visit: June 2019
Reviewed October 25, 2018

This is a one horse town, but you can get an excellent pizza here. Delicious crust. The pasta dinners are good too. I ordered a small antipasto as well, and it was huge.

Date of visit: October 2018
Reviewed October 14, 2018

We tried their calzones for the first time and were wildly surprised. The crust was great, the portion was generous, and the fillings were excellent. We asked for minced garlic in our calzones even though it is not on their menu and they accommodated us.

Date of visit: October 2018
Reviewed July 9, 2018

Great food, we had a Hawaiian Pizza which was amazing. Service was really good. Location is close to the Motel.

Date of visit: July 2018
Reviewed July 7, 2018 via mobile

Well if your in this town you know the water stinks and theres not much to eat. Thankfully this place is pretty awesome. The garlic Knotts were amazing. The pizza was isn't top 10, but it definitely hits the spot

Date of visit: July 2018
Reviewed June 18, 2018 via mobile

I love these type of places - one off and in a small town - with great food and great prices!! Terrific employees with wonderful food. $50.27 for four - entrees, garlic knots, fries, salads and soda drinks. Wish I lived around here!!

Date of visit: June 2018
View more reviews
Best nearby
Best nearby hotelsSee all
The Village Motel
52 reviews
.20 miles away
Fountain View Motel
43 reviews
.96 miles away
The Lake House
209 reviews
1.26 miles away
Lake N Pines Motel
226 reviews
5.87 miles away
Best nearby restaurantsSee all
Tally-Ho Restaurant
71 reviews
.49 miles away
Cassidy's Diner
21 reviews
.07 miles away
Foo Chow Restaurant
41 reviews
.07 miles away
Best nearby attractionsSee all
Petrified Creatures
15 reviews
2.13 miles away
Otsego Golf Club
9 reviews
5.65 miles away
Holy Trinity Monastery
21 reviews
5.76 miles away
Fly Creek Cider Mill & Orchard
420 reviews
8.95 miles away
Questions & Answers
Get quick answers from New York Pizzeria staff and past visitors.
Note: your question will be posted publicly on the Questions & Answers page.
Posting guidelines
Is This Your Listing?
Own or manage this property? Claim your listing for free to respond to reviews, update your profile and much more.
Claim Your Free Listing
Frequently Asked Questions about New York Pizzeria

Yes, New York Pizzeria offers takeout services.

New York Pizzeria is rated accordingly in the following categories by Tripadvisor travelers:
  • Food: 4
  • Service: 4
  • Value: 4
  • Atmosphere: 3.5