This was our first time here and we will be back for sure. The food is good and the service very good.
1 - 10 of 189 reviews
We have been here before. We took a total of nine people after a Marist Graduation Ceremony. We had reservations and they sat us right away. Our meals ranged from appetizers of calamari , antipasti,and mussels to dinners from pizza to pork catchitori. The Service...More
Our son goes to Marist College. We tried Cosimo's once and always return when we are in town as the food is excellent. We usually sit on the patio outdoors during spring and summer. The wait staff are very welcoming and excellent. Complimentary Italian bread...More
Not big on restaurant group style places because they tend to lack authenticity and originality. That said, I thought Cosimo's did a great job with nice touches such as the bread and olives on the table, the food is actually prepared by a chef, you...More
There is a wide variety of food here, mostly Italian. I had the snapper with cauliflower and it was all supposed to be gluten free. The snapper was overcooked and the cauliflower had smoke flavoring added to it. I did not care for either and...More
decent Italian food and great margaritas! We had a big group but service was good, we were starving by the time we arrived after a long trip, but bread and apps held us over until the pizza arrived, which I would highly recommend!
Cosimo's is BEAUTIFUL! When we were there, there was a large party on the first floor so there was limited seating. We still only had to wait about 20 minutes which was impressive. We had the fried risotto balls and they were amazing. The portions...More
Was part of a retirement party and was impressed with the efficiency of our servers. They were right there when yo needed them. The food was all appreciated by those who ordered. I had the eggplant and it was delicious.
Went with a group of 10 for a birthday dinner. The food was great, no complaints on that end however the service was horrible! When making the reservation, we were not told that the restaurant could only do 5 checks for big groups or that...More
I can’t say anything about the food because it was just that awful. The service was subpar at best. The food quality was low. The pizza was greasy that I could have lubed the chassis of my truck twice. The pasta was over cooked and...More