We noticed that you're using an unsupported browser. The TripAdvisor website may not display properly.We support the following browsers: Windows: Internet Explorer, Mozilla Firefox, Google Chrome. Mac: Safari.
All reviews lobster burger truffle fries caesar salad great view service was great high season awesome sunset restaurant staff outdoor seating make reservations pina colada great seafood rocket fuel deck bay island
We went to Macguire’s several times on our stay.
Great big terrace dining on the bay.
Fish tacos and ceaser wraps for lunch. Steaks and seafood for dinner.
It also has a gorgeous bar catering to people who are not drunk teenagers.
As is it seems everything on Fire Island, Maguire's is an overpriced dining option. It has a large amount of seating, most of which is covered. Of course, on a sunny day with four families and a dozen kids, the hostess stuck us in direct...More
Stopped by for lunch with the family, great location. Nice view of the water and right by a playground next to the police station.
The atmosphere was nice but the food was disappointing. Took awhile and lacked flavor and taste, the price was high also....More
What a great place to eat and grab a few with your friends. The view is awesome and the service can get slow sometimes in the high season, but it's packed for a reason. The food is very good and atmosphere is even better.
Eight of us had dinner on the deck on Sunday about 5 PM (2 were under 8 yrs old), and we had a good experience. Our server, Ron, was attentive and helpful, though the restaurant didn't enable him to offer some food options that we'd...More
The nighttime menu is very limited mostly fish with I think one meat items short ribs I think if you call ahead you can find out if they can make the fish gluten-free I really don't think that's a problem the luncheon menu... More
The nighttime menu is very limited mostly fish with I think one meat items short ribs I think if you call ahead you can find out if they can make the fish gluten-free I really don't think that's a problem the luncheon menu is much bigger I'm sure you could find something on that menu which might be to your satisfaction
Are you sure you want to delete this answer?
Is This Your TripAdvisor Listing?
Own or manage this property? Claim your listing for free to respond to reviews, update your profile and much more. Claim Your Listing