I've been going here for years! Just like the deli, the pizzeria is awesome!! They have a good variety of pasta dishes, salads, subs, and the pizza is delicious. The staff is always friendly!
1 - 10 of 16 reviews
Mama Theresa's is located in a strip mall on Windsor Highway. We almost missed it and drove by the first time. The return was worth it. The waitresses were great and the food was wonderful and inexpensive. We had pizza and linguini with tomato sauce...More
We went as a family to Mama Theresa's for dinner. Waitress was very friendly and attentive. The menu has a very wide variety which can make choosing a meal a lil hard, but definitely not a bad thing. We all ordered pasta/ chicken dishes and...More
My Favorite Italian restaurant. Great homemade soups served with a warm roll and butter. Suggest the eggplant tower (usually listed as a special appetizer) enough to be a meal. Chicken Marsala also a favorite, not typical it is made with a Sweet Marsala wine. Can't...More
My favorite pizza place - their Neapolitan is the best! I don't care for the dinner entrees. Stick with the pizza and you can't go wrong1
We always stop in for a meal when we are in town. The food is tasty and the service is great. Be sure to make this a stop when you are in New Windsor
Everything is fresh and super tasty and prepared as you order. The rice balls are the best I've ever had!!!! Staff aims to please!!!
Whatever you pick: pizza, dinners - you will never be disappointed. First class food. It is so good that we had then cater our wedding. Guests were blown away by the food!
We had a group of about 18 for a family birthday celebration on a Sunday afternoon. The service was fantastic. Our waitress even helped us serve the birthday cake we'd brought in. The service was attentive and quick. And the pizza is delicious!! Several got...More