We noticed that you're using an unsupported browser. The TripAdvisor website may not display properly.We support the following browsers:
Windows: Internet Explorer, Mozilla Firefox, Google Chrome. Mac: Safari.
TripAdvisor
New Paltz
Trips
Inbox
More
    Help Center

    Gadaleto's Seafood Market

    Save
    112 reviews
    #7 of 63 Restaurants in New Paltz
    $$ - $$$, American, Seafood, Gluten Free Options
    246 Main St Ste 1, Cherry Hill Center, New Paltz, NY 12561-1621
    +1 845-255-1717
    Website
    Menu
    Closed Now:See all hours
    All photos (14)
    All photos (14)

    Ratings and reviews

    4.5 112 reviews
    #7 of 63 Restaurants in New Paltz, New York
    Certificate of Excellence2016 - 2017 Winner
    RATINGS
    Food
    Service
    Value
    Atmosphere

    Location and contact

    246 Main St Ste 1 Cherry Hill Center, New Paltz, NY 12561-1621

    Menu

    STARTERS​
    Soups
    New england clam chowder / soup du jour cup 4 / bowl 5
    $8
    Crab Cake
    The original
    $8
    Calamari
    Lightly fried, with marinara sauce
    $8
    Shrimp Cocktail
    Chilled shrimp with cocktail sauce & lemon
    $9
    Buffalo Popcorn Shrimp
    Little fried shrimps, tossed in spicy buffalo sauce, with blue cheese dressing
    $12
    Littleneck Clams
    Steamed or on the half shell (dozen)
    $10
    Shrimp & Grit Cakes
    Blackened shrimp atop fried grits, with chipotle mayo
    $8
    Fried Clam Strips
    With cocktail sauce
    $10
    White wine
    Fra diablo
    Beer
    Steamed Mussels
    With garlic bread
    $11
    Fried East Coast Oysters
    With chipotle mayo
    SALADS​
    $6
    The Simple Salad
    Mesclun & veggies with balsamic vinaigrette
    $10
    The Not-So-Simple Salad
    Beets, bleu cheese, candied walnuts & red onion over mesclun, with house-made raspberry vinaigrette
    $10
    The Caesar Sald
    House-made caesar dressing over romaine, with croutons & parmigiano
    Made Your Salad a Meal:  add any fish from our daily selection.  prices vary
    SANDWICHES​
    All sandwiches served with coleslaw
    $12
    Po' Boy
    Fried oysters & chipotle mayo
    $12
    Jooba Doobie
    Grilled shrimp, BBQ sauce & frizzled onions
    $16
    Lobster Roll
    Lobster​ meat tossed in house-made tartar sauce
    $10
    Salmon Burger
    House-made salmon patty
    $12
    Crab Cake
    Maryland style crab cake
    $12
    Fish Tacos
    Crispy fried fish, pickled cabbage, lettuce, carrots, pico & chipotle mayo
    Want to make up your own sandwich?  Choose your fish & how you want it cooked and we'll put it on a toasted bun.  prices vary
    ENTREES​
    $14
    Old school $light & crispy
    English $beer battered & fluffy
    Southern $cornmeal crusted
    Fish & Chips
    With your choice of tarar/cocktail
    $22
    Stuffed Trout
    Lemon & herb stuffed rainbow trout, grilled. With your choice of two sides
    $Mkt
    Lobster Bake
    Clams, mussels, coleslaw
    $24
    Bouillabaisse
    Lobster & saffron broth, fennel & veggies, with daily fresh market fish
    $26
    Captain's Combo
    Crab stuffed with flounder, scallops & shrimp. Broiled/fried with two sides.
    $28
    Steak & a Cake
    House​ ribeye & maryland style crab cake, with your choice of two sides
    $20
    Shrimp Scampi
    Sauteed jumbo shrimp in a garlic, white wine & bitter sauce over linguini
    $18
    Vongole
    Chopped & whole clams in a garlic & white wine sauce, over linguini
    $22
    Scallop Primavera
    Scallop pieces with sauteed vegetables, in a garlic & butter sauce over linguini
    $24
    Lobster Diablo
    Lobster in homemade spicy marinara, over linguini
    ANY FISH DISH YOU WISH​
    Grilled with red pepper pesto
    Blackened with chipotle mayo
    Fried with tartar or cocktail
    Broiled with roasted garlic cream sauce
    Choose any fish from our fresh selection and how you want it cooked
    All platters come with choice of two sides. Prices vary by fish selection
    SIDES​
    $3
    Fries
    $3
    Coleslaw
    $3
    House Rice
    $3
    Roasted Potatoes
    $4
    Sweet Potato Fries
    $4
    Beet Salad
    $4
    Veggies
    $4
    Grit Cakes
    $6
    Salad
    All substitutions are at the chef's discretion and subject to additional charges. Consumption of raw or undercooked seafood, poultry or meat may increase risk of food borne illness. 18% gratuity added for parties of 6 or more.
    Show full menu
    DetailsImprove this listing
    About
    Your Hudson Valley Seafood Source, independent, family owned mom & pop shop. Fresh fish market open daily, with adjacent full service dining room open Wednesday through Monday.
    PRICE RANGE
    $8 - $28
    Special Diets
    Gluten Free Options
    Meals
    Lunch, Dinner
    CUISINES
    American, Seafood
    FEATURES
    Takeout, Seating, Waitstaff, Parking Available, Wheelchair Accessible, Wine and Beer
    Reviews (112)
    Write a Review
    Filter reviews
    112 results
    Traveler rating
    58
    42
    6
    4
    2
    Traveler type
    Time of year
    LanguageEnglish
    58
    42
    6
    4
    2
    Show reviews that mention
    All reviews fresh fish seafood lobster roll clams rainbow trout arctic char new england clam chowder beet salad monkfish bread roast potatoes crab cakes fries sandwich simple salad the jersey shore dining space
    FilterEnglish
    Updating list...
    1 - 10 of 112 reviews
    Reviewed 1 week ago
    Excellent source for fish and seafood in a village in the Hudson Valley

    Very few small towns or villages have the quality and quantity of seafood that Gadaleto's provides in New Paltz. Both the market and the restaurant offer an usual range of seafood options from fresh oysters and live lobsters to 20-30 species of fish. We shop...More

    Date of visit: January 2019
    Thank trocc0_12
    Reviewed November 8, 2018
    Good fish but sauces could be better

    We went on the spur of the moment. We had to wait a few minutes which gave us the chance to study the fish they had in the store. Thus we ordered an unusual fish: Tripletail. A nice, mild fish, prepared just right. However, the...More

    Date of visit: November 2018
    Thank Gypsgris
    Reviewed November 4, 2018 via mobile
    Sunday night dinner

    Beer, Narragansett, suggested by the manager, perfect. New England clam chowder, perfect. Oysters, salty? Briny? Or Meaty? Briny, daisy from PEI, perfect. Choice of fish entrees.... Too many... Had Florida grouper, broiled, with a butter wine garlic sauce, side of grilled asparagus , roasted baby...More

    Date of visit: November 2018
    Thank MarianneG465
    Reviewed October 3, 2018
    Best seafood market & restaurant in New Paltz

    Great variety of fresh fish cooked in different ways. You get to choose the way you like it, grilled, broiled, or fried.

    Date of visit: September 2018
    Thank adrianadelaspozas
    Reviewed August 28, 2018
    Everything done to perfection!

    Food simply prepared, but with attention to flavor detail. Wonderful fried oysters. So many fresh fish of the day options! I had the skate. Delicious with an unusual side of cold beet salad which was fresh and not soaked in vinegar. Also some unusual beer...More

    Date of visit: August 2018
    Thank thebub2018
    Reviewed August 7, 2018
    Great seafood eat in or take out.

    It's a place where you can eat in or take out they also have where you can buy the seafood and cook it home. Resturant and store all in one food is very fresh they get it every day

    Date of visit: July 2018
    Thank Ricardo R
    Reviewed July 22, 2018
    Best Seafood In The Area

    I've been going to Gadaleto's for years and it certainly deserves a review. If you enjoy fresh fish, do yourself a favor and give Gadaletos's a shot. I've never had a bad meal there. My favorite is their Oyster Po' Boy and, if I can...More

    Date of visit: July 2018
    1  Thank Exciteableboy
    Reviewed July 16, 2018 via mobile
    Just off the highway on our way through!

    On our way home from a trip to NYC we stopped for dinner. The food was excellent and the service was great. My only complaint is the restaurant isn’t very family friendly no kids menu or high chairs. Otherwise we had a great meal would...More

    Date of visit: July 2018
    Thank natashad381
    Reviewed July 16, 2018
    10 year in the making lobster dinner

    My Dad has been living in the mid-west for years and the only seafood restaurant there is Red Lobster. He has been looking forward to a "REAL" lobster dinner for over a year as we planned a trip back to NY. He is NOT a...More

    Date of visit: July 2018
    Thank Z4486COlaurap
    Reviewed July 10, 2018
    Fresh fish, well,prepared

    Gadaleto’s sells fresh fish in a small store and also has a restaurant and takeout operation. Everything is very fresh and the quality is consistent. Favorites are the crab cakes and the Captain’s Combo but you must also try the sweet potato fries and the...More

    Date of visit: June 2018
    Thank Bonnie M
    View more reviews
    123456…12
    See all
    Questions & Answers
    Ask a question
    See all 5 questions
    U7574IBjosephm
    August 26, 2018|
    AnswerShow all 3 answers
    Response from fba5 | Reviewed this property |
    Per their website, their Not So-Simple-Salad consists of: "beets, bleu cheese, candied walnuts & red onion over mesclun, with house-made raspberry vinaigrette."
    0
    Votes
    C3400OEjeffa
    March 5, 2018|
    Answer
    Response from Tara S | Reviewed this property |
    No they serve beer and wine
    0
    Votes
    GeraldineG177
    September 17, 2017|
    AnswerShow all 2 answers
    Response from BobsBeenThereToo | Reviewed this property |
    Don't know either, but call them. 845-255-1717. Get the info directly. For sure, they can get you clams!
    0
    Votes
    12
    Is This Your TripAdvisor Listing?
    Own or manage this property? Claim your listing for free to respond to reviews, update your profile and much more. Claim Your Listing