We noticed that you're using an unsupported browser. The TripAdvisor website may not display properly.We support the following browsers:
Windows: Internet Explorer, Mozilla Firefox, Google Chrome. Mac: Safari.

Mama Theresa's Pizzeria Restaurant

Unclaimed

Ratings and reviews

Certificate of Excellence2015 - 2019 Winner
RATINGS
Food
Service
Value
Atmosphere

Details

CUISINES
Italian, Pizza
Special Diets
Vegetarian Friendly
Meals
Lunch, Dinner, Late Night
View all details
meals, features

Location and contact

Menu

APPETIZERS‎
10.25
Clams Oreganata
(6) whole baked little neck clams
11.75
Fried Calamari Golden Fried Calamari Served w/ a Side of Homemade Marinara Sauce
7.75
Mozzarella Sticks
(6) served w/ a side of Italian tomato sauce
4.25
With melted mozzarella cheese +5.25
garlic bread Italian bread basted w/ fresh garlic, virgin olive oil & imported spices, baked to perfection.
10.95
Mozzarella Di Casa Homemade Mozzarella, Roasted Red Peppers, Tomatoes & Basil, Virgin Olive Oil & Balsamic Vinegar
15.95
Hot Antipasto
(Serves‎ 2) a combination of our eggplant rollatini, baked clams, shrimp oreganata, mozzarella sticks & stuffed mushrooms
Zuppa Di Cozze
(Red or white) fresh cultivated mussels, steamed & seasoned in a white wine garlic & herb broth or in a marinara tomato
Red
White
Sauce11.95
14.50
Calamari Arrabbiata
(Serves‎ 2) freshly battered calamari tossed w/ flame roasted peppers sauteed in a “spicy” arrabbiata style plum tomato sauce
9.25
Zucchini Fritti Handcut Zucchini, Lightly Battered, Pan Fried & Nested Over Marinara Sauce
SOUPS‎
6.25
Quart size soups 12.00
Tortellini in Brodo Cheese Tortellini in a Light Chicken Broth
6.25
Quart size soups 12.00
Pasta E Fagioli Small Tubular Pasta, White Cannellini Beans, Fresh Plum Tomato, Garlic & Extra Virgin Olive Oil
6.25
Quart size soups 12.00
Stracciatella Soup Spinach & Eggdrop in a Light Chicken Broth
6.25
Quart size soups 12.00
Minestrone Hearty Vegetable Soup
6.25
Quart size soups 12.00
Homemade Chicken Soup Chicken Strips & Noodles in a Hearty Broth
6.25
Quart size soups 12.00
Lentil Soup
Lentils in a hearty homemade vegetable broth
SALADS‎
Side
Entree
Fresh Tossed House Salad
A combination of iceberg & romaine lettuce, tomatoes, cucumbers, carrots, red peppers & black olives w/ our famous
Side 4.75
Entree 7.25
Italian dressing
Side 5.75
Entree 8.25
Caesar Salad
Romaine lettuce topped w/ homemade garlic croutons, aged parmesan cheese & caesar dressing
Side 8.25
Entree 11.25
Pecan Salad
Fresh mesculin greens, tossed w/ arugula, Belgian endive, radicchio, honey glazed pecans & imported gorgonzola cheese w/ our homemade balsamic vinaigrette dressing
Side Na
Entree 11.50
Tuna Salad Platter
Tossed salad topped w/ our delicious homemade tuna
Side Na
Entree 11.25
Grilled Chicken Salad
Tossed‎ salad & fresh grilled chicken strips
Side Na
Entree 12.25
Buffalo Chicken Salad
Spicy chicken strips, romaine & iceberg lettuce mixture, tossed w/ bleu cheese dressing & topped w/ bruschetta tomatoes
Side Na
Entree 8.95
Bistro Salad
mesculin greens, tossed w/ diced tomatoes, red onions, drizzled w/ our tuscan style Italian dressing
Side Na
Entree 9.95
Caprino Salad
Mesclun greens, roasted peppers, grilled asparagus, crumbled goat cheese, cherry tomatoes, red onions, balsamic vinaigrette
Side Na
Entree 11.50
Cold Antipasto
(serves 2) garden salad, assorted Italian cold cuts, fresh cheeses & our Italian style house dressing
HEROS AND PLATTERS‎
All platters served w/ choice of tossed house salad, caesar salad, pasta tomato sauce or French fries.
Hero 8.95
Platter 15.50
Tossed house salad
Caesar salad
Pasta tomato sauce
French fries.
Eggplant or Meatball or Sausage Parmigiana
Hero 10.75
Platter 17.25
Tossed house salad
Caesar salad
Pasta tomato sauce
French fries.
Veal Cutlet Parmigiana
Hero 9.75
Platter 16.25
Tossed house salad
Caesar salad
Pasta tomato sauce
French fries.
Chicken Cutlet Parmigiana
Hero 11.25
Platter 17.75
Tossed house salad
Caesar salad
Pasta tomato sauce
French fries.
Jumbo Shrimp Parmigiana
Hero 9.25
Platter 15.75
Tossed house salad
Caesar salad
Pasta tomato sauce
French fries.
Sausage & Pepper Hero
Hero 9.75
Platter 16.25
Tossed house salad
Caesar salad
Pasta tomato sauce
French fries.
Grilled Chicken Cutlet Parmigiana
Hero 8.50
Platter Na
Tossed house salad
Caesar salad
Pasta tomato sauce
French fries.
Tuna Hero
Hero 9.75
Platter Na
Tossed house salad
Caesar salad
Pasta tomato sauce
French fries.
Grilled Chicken or Fried Chicken Club
served w/ lettuce, tomato, mayonnaise & Italian dressing (melted mozzarella cheese $1.00 extra)
PASTA‎
Choice of: spaghetti, fettuccine, rigatoni, penne, linguine, fusilli, capellini, farfalle, whole wheat pasta
With meatball or sausage lunch +8.95
With meatball or sausage dinner +13.75
Lunch 6.50
Dinner 9.95
traditional Italian tomato sauce
Lunch 8.50
Dinner 12.50
Rigatoni Marinara
fresh Italian tomatoes sauteed w/ garlic, olive oil & spices
Lunch 11.25
Dinner 17.25
Penne Oreganate
Fresh shrimp & asparagus sauteed in a classic garlic & white wine scampi sauce topped off w/ toasted bread crumbs
Lunch 9.25
Dinner 14.25
Penne Bolognese
Freshly ground hearty meat sauce w/ a touch of cream
Red sauce
White sauce
Lunch 10.75
Dinner 16.75
Linguine Clam Sauce
(Red or white) chopped baby clams sauteed w/ fresh garlic & oil & w/ whole shelled little neck clams
Anchovies +1.50
Lunch 8.50
Dinner 12.50
Spaghetti Garlic & Oil
sauteed fresh garlic, extra virgin olive oil & Italian seasoning
Red sauce
White sauce
Lunch 9.25
Dinner 13.95
Farfalle Broccoli
(Red or white) sauteed broccoli w/ fresh garlic in a light red or white light garlic brodino sauce
Lunch 9.50
Dinner 14.50
Fettuccine Alla Mama Theresa
Alfredo cream sauce combined w/ green peas, onions & ham, topped over fresh fettuccine
Lunch 8.95
Dinner 13.75
Fusilli Al Pesto
fresh basil sauce combined w/ grated parmigiana cheese, pignoli nuts & Italian seasonings
BAKED PASTA‎
Baked Ravioli 11.50
11.50
Baked Homemade Lasagna
Baked Manicotti 11.50
Baked Ziti 11.50
12.50
Baked Ziti Siciliana
With fresh battered eggplant
SIDE ORDERS‎
Side of spaghetti or penne w/ one of the following sauces
6.50
Spaghetti
Penne
Garlic & extra virgin olive oil
Marinara sauce
Tomato Sauce
8.50
Spaghetti
Penne
Garlic & extra virgin olive oil
Marinara sauce
Marinara Sauce
8.50
Spaghetti
Penne
Garlic & extra virgin olive oil
Marinara sauce
Pink Sauce
8.50
Spaghetti
Penne
Garlic & extra virgin olive oil
Marinara sauce
Garlic & Oil
9.25
Spaghetti
Penne
Garlic & extra virgin olive oil
Marinara sauce
Bolognese
8.95
Spaghetti
Penne
Garlic & extra virgin olive oil
Marinara sauce
Alfredo
7.95
Spaghetti
Penne
Garlic & extra virgin olive oil
Marinara sauce
Grilled or Fried Chicken
2 pieces
7.50
Spaghetti
Penne
Garlic & extra virgin olive oil
Marinara sauce
homemade “Italian style” meatballs tomato sauce
4
7.50
Spaghetti
Penne
Garlic & extra virgin olive oil
Marinara sauce
homemade “Italian style” fresh sauteed sausage
3
ENTREE DISHES‎
All platters served w/ choice of a side house salad, caesar salad, pasta tomato sauce or French fries.
17.75
Side house salad
Caesar salad
Pasta tomato sauce
French fries
Eggplant Rollatini
Fresh eggplant rolled w/ whole milk ricotta & topped w/ melted mozzarella cheese & fresh tomato sauce
Side house salad
Caesar salad
Pasta tomato sauce
French fries
Grilled Chicken Primavera
Fresh breast of chicken marinated in balsamic vinegar & imported seasonings, grilled & topped w/ a medley of sauteed
19.50
Side house salad
Caesar salad
Pasta tomato sauce
French fries
Fresh Vegetables
16.25
Side house salad
Caesar salad
Pasta tomato sauce
French fries
Grilled Balsamic Chicken
Fresh‎ breast of chicken marinated in balsamic vinegar, olive oil & spices, then grilled to perfection
19.95
Side house salad
Caesar salad
Pasta tomato sauce
French fries
Chicken Verdi
Battered breast of chicken sauteed in butter & white wine w/ fresh broccoli or spinach & melted mozzarella cheese
Chicken 19.95
Veal 20.95
Shrimp 21.95
Side house salad
Caesar salad
Pasta tomato sauce
French fries
Francese
Battered‎ breast of chicken, veal or shrimp sauteed in lemon, butter & white wine
Chicken 19.95
Veal 20.95
Side house salad
Caesar salad
Pasta tomato sauce
French fries
Marsala
Tender breast of chicken or veal, sauteed in imported marsala wine & mushroom
19.95
Side house salad
Caesar salad
Pasta tomato sauce
French fries
Chicken Alla Vodka
Tender pieces of chicken sauteed in vodka sauce & portobello mushrooms, topped off w/ fresh mozzarella
18.25
Side house salad
Caesar salad
Pasta tomato sauce
French fries
Chicken Alla Marco
Fresh breast of chicken grilled to perfection then smothered w/ our delicious bruschetta. A delight!
SPECIALTY DISHES‎
Served alla carte
19.95
Grilled Salmon
Grilled‎ salmon over a bed of sauteed spinach & cannelini beans, extra virgin olive oil
19.95
Grilled Swordfish
Grilled swordfish served w/ a mesclun salad & string beans
Branzino Mediterraneo
Oven roasted mediterranean sea bass filet, drizzled w/ an extra virgin olive oil, lemon & fresh herb marinade, served with
21.95
Sauteed Spinach
15.95
Eggplant Siciliana
Breaded, sicilian style eggplant, topped w/ fresh mozzarella, spinach & tomato sauce
19.95
Surf & Turf
Marinated skirt steak w/ grilled shrimp served over mesclun greens
PIZZETTAS‎
Traditional 9.50
Whole wheat bar pizza “thin crust” 9.50
Gluten free 11.50
Pizzetta
Our version of a classic regular pie, but smaller!
Traditional 12.75
Whole wheat bar pizza “thin crust” 12.75
Gluten free 14.75
Margherita Pizzetta
Plum tomato sauce mixed w/ basil, oregano & grated cheese topped w/ fresh mozzarella slices
Traditional 13.50
Whole wheat bar pizza “thin crust” 13.50
Gluten free 15.50
Fra Diavolo Pizzetta
San marzano tomato sauce, crumbled sausage, pepperoni,& thin sliced cherry peppers, topped off w/ mozzarella cheese
Traditional 12.95
Whole wheat bar pizza “thin crust” 12.95
Gluten free 14.95
Salad Pizzetta
chopped garden salad served over a crispy round pizza crust, drizzled w/ our own traditional Italian dressing
Traditional 13.50
Whole wheat bar pizza “thin crust” 13.50
Gluten free 15.50
Prosciutto & Arugula
Fresh mozzarella, imported fontina cheese, “parma” prosciutto, arugula, white truffle oil drizzle, shaved reggiano cheese
Traditional 13.25
Whole wheat bar pizza “thin crust” 13.25
Gluten free Na
Alla Melenzane
Plum tomato sauce mixed w/ basil, oregano & grated cheese topped w/ fresh mozzarella slices & battered eggplant
Traditional 12.95
Whole wheat bar pizza “thin crust” 12.95
Gluten free Na
Buffalo Pizzetta
Our famous buffalo chicken w/ melted mozzarella & bleu cheese
Traditional 6.95
Whole wheat bar pizza “thin crust” Na
Gluten free Na
Kids Pizzetta
(8”) our thin crust individual pizza made to suit any child, additional toppings available
Traditional
Whole wheat bar pizza “thin crust”
Gluten free
Create Your Own
Reviews (145)
Filter reviews
144 results
Traveler rating
66
56
17
2
3
Traveler type
Time of year
LanguageEnglish
Traveler rating
66
56
17
2
3
Show reviews that mention
All reviews salad pizza penne chicken pie bread front counter lunch specials are excellent food and service great sauce quick service portions are large an entree take out love this place new york arnold
Selected filters
FilterEnglish
Updating list...
1 - 10 of 144 reviews
Reviewed 1 week ago

We have dinner at Mama after returning from an oversea trip because my family said it was always busy which is a good sign. So they were absolutely right! I had the clam pasta and it was delicious.

Date of visit: May 2019
Thank leedjjck
Reviewed May 9, 2019 via mobile

Food is quality, service is good, ambiance is ok. Whether you are poppung in for a slice or sotting down for a meal you wont go wrong here

Date of visit: May 2019
Thank Cat D
Reviewed April 27, 2019

When visiting relatives who live in the area, we always go to Mama Theresa's. The Chicken Vodka is fabulous. My nephew loves the Gnocchi Arnold. I went for the comfort food - meatballs overs penne. The staff are great, attentive but not overbearing. Portions are...More

Date of visit: April 2019
Thank Robert F
Reviewed March 19, 2019 via mobile

No reservations accepted but the wait was minor as the 20 + tables turn over quickly. Service is attentive and knowledgeable about the good menu. Wine is fair and beer selection is limited. You will not be disappointed with the food..

Date of visit: March 2019
Thank IRISHNHP
Reviewed February 26, 2019 via mobile

My family and I love Mama Theresa’s. We have done take out and eat in. Always good. Service is excellent too. We love their bread the best.

Date of visit: February 2019
1  Thank Mary F
Reviewed January 15, 2019

Have frequented this restaurant several times and have always found the food to be very good and the value for the price to be excellent.

Date of visit: July 2018
Thank DCattani
Reviewed December 30, 2018

While this is a pizzeria, the food is a cut above "pizzeria" in my book. Our party enjoyed: 1. chicken platter (grilled) which had a beautiful side salad as an option; both side salad and the platter were colorful, 2. oreganate penne, 3. baked lasagna,...More

Date of visit: December 2018
Thank Beth E
Reviewed December 11, 2018

The food is tremendous and the service was exceptional. A wonderful dining experience for a large group - all food arrived quickly and hot. Very good menu selection with wine pairing suggestions. Super service.

Date of visit: November 2018
Thank 942LindaP
Reviewed November 6, 2018 via mobile

I have been a customer for decades, literally. Quality has always been maintained. We love the chicken parmigiana platter that come with the salad. The salad is not some small lettuce salad. It is a big salad with roasted peppers, a few olives, tomatoes and...More

Date of visit: November 2018
Thank pulgany
Reviewed September 6, 2018

The restaurant is busy with old school look. They are family friendly (even for the 3 year-old!). The prices for an entree are on the high side but the portions are large (and it is the NYC area!) The four of us shared the Veal...More

Date of visit: August 2018
Thank MrPickwick
View more reviews
Nearby
Nearby HotelsSee all nearby hotels
SpringHill Suites Carle Place Garden City
226 reviews
2.07 miles away
Homewood Suites by Hilton Carle Place - Garden City
788 reviews
2.12 miles away
Hampton Inn Garden City
786 reviews
2.61 miles away
Hyatt Place Garden City
710 reviews
2.65 miles away
Nearby RestaurantsSee all 112 nearby restaurants
Jonathan's Restaurant
134 reviews
.02 miles away
Uncle Bacala's Italian Seafood & More
98 reviews
.01 miles away
Spanky's Food Factory
11 reviews
.09 miles away
Nearby AttractionsSee all 6 nearby attractions
Cellar 25
5 reviews
.64 miles away
Memories pub
6 reviews
1.22 miles away
Can You Escape LI
265 reviews
1.31 miles away
American Guitar Museum
6 reviews
1.43 miles away
Questions & Answers
Get quick answers from Mama Theresa's Pizzeria Restaurant staff and past visitors.
Note: your question will be posted publicly on the Questions & Answers page.
Submit
Posting guidelines
Is This Your Listing?
Own or manage this property? Claim your listing for free to respond to reviews, update your profile and much more.
Claim Your Free Listing