Greatest jelly croissants ever and very friendly people. It is a must stop for me every time I am out there.

Saw a huge line so we thought it was worth the wait. It’s not. Completely overrated breakfast wraps that had no taste and felt like I got it from a crappy deli. Waited to place our order and it took 1 hour total. Skip.

I was so excited to go to this bake shoppe. It has such high ratings. We went in the afternoon to order lunch and to try some of their scrumptious goodies. I ordered 4 chocolate rugelach and a chocolate chip scone . I also ordered...a turkey wrap and my husband ordered a crispy chicken wrap which were $12 each. While we were waiting, I started to look at all the scrumptious goodies in the cases. It was then that I noticed the bees. As another customer pointed out, the bees were climbing on the pastries and the employees did not do anything about it. The 3 stars are for the food. Everything was delicious, but something should be done about the bees climbing on the food they are selling. A simple solution would be to install a screen door, (The door is wide open for air) and to put a sliding door behind each case so the bees can't go into the pastry cases. As soon as that is fixed, I would give it 5 stars.More

My husband and I frequent Montauk and always make it a point to stop at the bake shop. Everything was pretty good until our last visit. I will never be back. The employees allowed at least 10 bees to crawl all over the doughnuts and...other baked goods. Absolutely disgusting!!! There wasn’t even any attempt at trying to remove the bees or at least throw out the food that had insects on it. No doubt they are selling the same baked goods and people are eating something that had bees crawling on it. I get that it’s Labor Day weekend and they are busy, and also that a bee can fly in with the door wide open, but come on that is disgusting. I wanted to vomit especially since my husband and I have eaten plenty of items from the shop in the past. I don’t even want to know how hygienic the rest of the food preparation is especially since I saw the cashier handle cash and go to make bagels without gloves or washing hands. Absolutely repulsive. I will never ever be back.More

Delish sweets and COFFEE! The line goes fast, whenever I am in town I need some JELLY DELICIOUSNESS from Montauk Bakery Shoppe. Manager was so awesome!

Long wait times for average quality food. Please note that this is a cash only place. Also check your receipt due to many places in Montauk "round up" to the next dollar which is illegal in the state of NY.

Have had these before, stopped by for another taste recently. Good but more greasy than I recall. Gave me indigestion.

You cannot go to Montauk and NOT visit the bake shoppe!!!! Everything is fresh daily! And there is always a line out the door in the mornings! They make the best egg sandwiches on Long Island!!!

Everything here is delicious especially the French toast and stuffed croissants. Always a line outside but worth the wait.

This bakery is AWESOME!! The line to get into this place is always long, prices are decent and the portion sizes are pretty big, definitely a must go to, be prepared to wait online because it’s THAT GOOD!!!

We’ve always loved the bakery. Been going there for decades. This year with Covid, we wanted more takeout breakfasts. Food is always fresh and delicious. And the staff is super patient and professional. Great part of Montauk’s tradition.

Jelly croissants and donuts are amazing! We have been coming here during our annual visits to Montauk - last year for some reason we were not thrilled with the cleanliness of the shop however everything was up to par again as it has been in...the past (different staff it appears?) We used to get the egg croissant sandwiches and in the past they were outstanding, however during this visit it was disappointing and just did not taste the same. We will stick to the croissants and donuts moving forward. Come for the baked goods and you’ll be happy!More