This is our third visit to Surfside. We had reservations on a Wednesday night( we didn't need to. ) We were seated at the last table by the window with the ocean view. Nice Our server quickly came over with water and what the specials...More
1 - 10 of 177 reviews
My wife and I have been here several times and were looking forward to another nice meal here. We took the time to read the reviews and scan the menu before hand. To our surprise, the prices were at least 25% higher than those listed...More
We hosted a family reunion dinner for our 25th Wedding Anniversary. Service was excellent, and the infused cocktails were delish. Shrimp Cocktail was very fresh, and the crab cake was tasty. The steak was very tough. Nice evening, but very pricy!
My wife and I took a long ride to go out to the wineries in the Hamptons and loved it. We wanted to go out east more in Montauk to have a nice dinner with a perfect view. We passed by the Surfside Inn and...More
out of the town area this restaurant is one of our favorites. nice outdoor patio seating and great views of the atlantic ocean. food and service is always top notch
A must visit while in Montauk...The Surfside Inn on old Montauk highway is conveniently lcoated just west of downtown...full menu with a compliment of Octoberfest items including susages with sauerkraut which I had and was very good...friendly/attentive service...reasonable prices
Went here recently with friends. The room was rather uncomfortable, and generally needed an upgrade. The food was mediocre, and the staff was pleasant enough. I ordered fish, which was overcooked and not very flavorful. I would pass on this place.
After 30 years of visiting Montauk area we finely found their hidden treasure in restaurants . The Surfside Inn on old Montauk highway is by far the best. On Sunday I had the most wonderful prepared fluke with Frances's sauce over a bed of spinach...More
Meal was very good, service was attentive, price was fair. Lobster rav and fresh cod both nicely prepared. As we stayed at Hartman's, right next door, we decided to once again visit the Surfside Inn. Its been a few years, no disappointments. Recommend to anyone...More