No frills, but delicious pizza. We always make it a point to order two personal pies when visiting Montauk. Our little tradition is when we check in at our favorite hotel, the Aqualina, we put in our pizza order and unpack. The wait is long...but soooo worth it. So we unpack and stroll around town to kill time. The pizza is truly the best. We can each eat our entire personal pie that’s how good this pizza is. My belly hurts but I keep eating. We have never been disappointed. I wish we had pizza this good where I live. As others have said, the wait is insanely long, but soooooo worth it. Put your order in and walk around town, or walk and hang on the beach to kill time.More

Always stop here when Im in the area. I order a pie $20. Great pizza and good service always. Only one con they only accept cash here.

We ordered pizza delivery at 6pm on a Wednesday thinking we would get ahead of the rush. They said it would take 1 hr and 15 mins - fine and appreciate the heads up. After several failed phone calls to inquire on status (their phones...were either off the hook or ringing off the hook), my husband went out to attempt to pick it up at 8pm. As he was on his way there, we got a call from the delivery person that it was out for delivery and would arrive in 7 mins. The food didn’t arrive until 8:30pm - almost 2:30 hours after I placed the order. The pizza was room temperature and the cheese was cold/hard. We had to reheat everything and actually cook the gluten free pizzas longer (seemed as if ingredients were merely warmed on the GF shell on it’s way out the door). Once reheated, the Sicilian and thin crust were a 6 or 7 out of 10. They could have been an 8 if it had arrived hot and fresh. The buffalo wings were pretty good reheated (they are coated FYI). The calamari didn’t weather the prolonged delivery and was cold, tough and coating/breading lacked any crispness. Better to pick up but still may have been a 2 hr wait — so proceed with caution…More

We placed an lunch order for 2 pizzas and chicken nuggets to be delivered to our hotel. Was told a time upon ordering and delivery driver arrived almost an hour late with ice cold food. All would have tasted good if at least been luke...warm. I suggest skipping delivery and picking up or try another place. No credit cards, cash only which is a negative!More

We ordered delivery to our hotel. It took over 2 hour, a lot longer than the 45 minutes they said. By the time it came everything was cold. We ordered delivery here last year and it was nowhere near as I good as I remember....The grandma pizza ap was average at best and the regular pizza was good.More

always stop her first night in Montauk. Food had little taste needed a lot more seasonjng. Very n land sauce tasted no garlic whatsoever.

The food was amazing and the service was unique! I strongly recommend this to anyone. Best pizza in Mintauk

Pizza and service were both great! Only pizza place open year round in Montauk. We will definitely try the food the next time we visit Montauk, but the pizza was excellent.

Seemed to be the only place open in the entire town. We had a similar experience three years ago. While ordering from a really sweet young girl at the counter, the pizzamaker behind her, interrupted us. He began berating her in Spanish, not knowing that...my husband and I are fluent. After screaming at her for a problem with a Margherita pizza, he made two really inappropriate comments about her body and things he wished to do. I literally could not believe it. The girl was a tough-cookie and battled through the sexual harassment to take my order. The crazy thing is, this same gentleman did the same thing to a female employee, who seemed to be Russian-speaking in the winter of 2017, the last time we were in Montauk for New Year's eve. I will never go back there again. To top it all off, when this gentleman took our pizza out of the oven it was undercooked, with tomato sauce liquid all over the box. Last time we go there.More

We loved the outdoor window ordering, We ate from here 2 nights straight. Both pasta and pizza were delicious. The food was prepared quick, and the price was right.

We have very bad experience. The man deals and order are a very confused. We order for fries, pizza slice and French fries. He told us it will take 45 minutes if we order vegetable pizza so we order for slices as he told it...will takes 15 minutes. We waited more than 2 hours and when asked how much waiting time then he show us much rough attitude. We never saw Italian restaurant so that type attitude. We are very disappointed.More

Whether plain, extra cheese, pepperoni or mushroom topping, you won’t be disappointed. Food is good but their pizza is great!