We noticed that you're using an unsupported browser. The TripAdvisor website may not display properly.We support the following browsers: Windows: Internet Explorer, Mozilla Firefox, Google Chrome. Mac: Safari.
All reviews ice cream cookie monster tongue homemade flavors mocha chip cakes almond joy there are so many north fork busy intersection excellent homemade on line friendly service long island magical lines summer
This is the ultimate ice cream store. Freshly homemade ice cream. They even have Vegan options. My very favorite ice cream store ever. Wish it were closer but then I would be there every day and gain a ton!
This ice cream is absolutely delicious. It’s creamy and the flavors are jam packed with fresh ingredients. My personal favorite is praline and cream. The pralines are sweet and crunchy and the ice cream is buttery is a hint of burnt sugar. Yum!
This is a mandatory stop for families visiting the North Fork this Summer and Fall. A bit pricey but worth every lick ! More flavors and ice cream "delivery systems" than you can easily choose from. High quality, friendly staff...dont drive by !
Magic Fountain has it all - a friendly and accommodating staff; high quality, delicious ice cream and toppings; and a welcoming atmosphere. Highly recommend trying their homemade flavors. Save yourself some trouble and park at 7-11 across the street and walk over. Only a few...More
Excellent home made ice cream. Sugar free and low fat options available as well. Lack of seating is the only downfall but it’s worth the trip for some of the best ice cream around. If you like your tongue blue try the Cookie Monster. My...More
Wow pistachio one of my favorites loaded with nuts. Best ice cream I have had in a while.
They have a plethora of flavors
I like the old favorites
And this was the perfect choice
Go there enjoy and have fine!
I reviewed this place in 2017 and I have visited it over the past 2 years. I was fortunate enough to receive a gift certificate from my friend for a favor I did for him last week and I assure you that ALL the ice...More