We ordered the calamari and polenta Calabrese as starters. Then we had Blackened scallops served over a creamy Italian risotto with a medley of portobello, shitake, and button mushrooms. Sautéed baby eggplant and zucchini in a pink sauce baked with fresh mozzarella. We also ordered...More

we dine here about once a month or more. never disappointed. we ask for the table near the fireplace - cozy and quiet. great food selection and bar. service is always knowledgeable and efficient. feels like a real neighborhood place - very friendly and plenty...More

Absolutely lovely dinner from start to finish. Beautiful restaurant inside; very friendly and attentive staff. Mussels marinara to start was on point. Blackened scallops over mushroom risotto was delicious - you could taste each type of mushroom in the risotto and the scallops were cooked...More

I guess I’ve been to Modern on the Rails about six times now. It is consistently a great experience. I usually eat the Chicken Scarpariello and tonight like all others it was excellent. Tender chicken accompanied by cherry peppers, potatoes, and sausage in a great...More

Lovely ambiance and great food! Come visit this hidden gem for a great night with friends or family.

DO NOT order food on Seamless. After waiting more than an hour and a half feel fortunate if your entire order arrives.That is a doubtful proposition.If you call them they will sound surprised that you didn't get it.HELLO!!!!!. Don't you know???

We came to see a band and were really impressed by the beautiful space and service. For food we only desserts which were incredible - cheesecake and rice pudding. Service was a 10 of 10. Wish we had not eaten before we had gone so...More

The atmosphere is very welcoming. They kept much of the facade of the original Mamaroneck Train Station, which is impressive. The food is very good and the waitstaff beyond pleasant. And that is why we keep going back. We took family and friends (a group...More

The location at the train station is unique. It's somewhat cavernous but still intimate. Service and food are excellent. Prices are appropriate. Our favorite is the calamari appetizer. Mamaroneck has plenty of wonderful restaurant choices; this is one of the best, with plenty of free...More

Quick snack and drink before going home. Great rye manhattans, salad and broccoli rabe. Stop here frequently after being in the city.