We noticed that you're using an unsupported browser. The Tripadvisor website may not display properly.We support the following browsers: Windows: Internet Explorer, Mozilla Firefox, Google Chrome. Mac: Safari.
Sadly Fingerlicks has closed and is up for sale. Stay tuned to see if there will be someone to take it over.More
Date of visit: December 2019
Mkkk123, Owner at Fingerlick's, responded to this reviewResponded January 8, 2020
Hi lakedude! Thank you for the comments, however we are closed for the season as we have always done and have listed the property as you noted. Be assured that we will be back open May 2020 doing what we always do which is serving...More
Stopped in for an ice cream cone and was amazed at the size of the cone compared to the cost. Great value. Warm and friendly staff. The owners were in sight and took the time to great their patrons. Will go back and definitely recommend...them to everyone.More
Review collected in partnership with this restaurant
This business uses tools provided by Tripadvisor (or one of its official Review Collection Partners) to encourage and collect guest reviews, including this one.
My family rented a house on Seneca Lake for the week and stopped here for dinner one night. To be honest, I was not expecting much from our meal, assuming it would all be fried food since Fingerlicks seems like it is mainly an ice...cream place. I can't believe how wrong I was!
I got a portabello sandwich and the mushroom was cooked perfectly. Four people in my party got a burger and they all said they were delicious (and they were pretty large as well!). My Mom got the chicken parm sandwich and really liked it but had trouble finishing it because it was so big. The ice cream was good too!
If you are in the area, I would highly recommend dropping by here for a meal. It doesn't look like much for the outside, but it is delicious and you will not be disappointed. When we are at the lake next year, we will definitely be having at least one meal here!More
This little house on the road by one of the Finger Lakes serves ice cream. They have a few tables outside. There is a gravel parking area. Icecream was fine but very large helpings. Odd service through a window.
I've been wanting to stop here for years! We are always driving by on our way to our campground, and I love ice cream, so this year I insisting on having their delicious ice cream three times! Fingerlicks is a throwback to the days of...getting a lot for your money, and you can tell they are doing something right---there are always lots of people there. I had one scoop of ice cream each time, and I don't think I've ever had such a big scoop, or ice cream so delicious. My favorite was the cappuccino crunch, but the bourbon truffle was yummy too. I actually wasn't able to finish my scoop in one sitting, but it tasted just as good later that night, or even the next day. I've heard good things about their seafood too, though we didn't get to try it. Next time!More
We have had dinner including the fresh fish, shrimp and scallops. Delicious! If Dark Chocolate Raspberry Truffle sounds good to you - you will not be disappointed! Have it in a waffle cone, and one scoop is plenty!
We look forward to stopping in at Fingerlicks every year we are in town. Best fish fry ever and their ice cream is soooo good! Very friendly staff and a very clean environment! Thank you Fingerlicks; keep up your awesomeness... We'll be back again next...year!More
My family of 13 walked in & immediately welcomed. Sad no clam strips on Sunday- we all enjoyed burgers (presented w/ the freshest lettuce, tomatoes & garnish w/ mini slice of cantalope-what a treat in a roadside stand!), chik tenders, buffalo fries!! All food came...out Hot! With a smile our Ice Cream orders were taken - the soft serve is top quality for all us Ice Cream addicts!! I presume the gentleman -chef- who came out while we were eating was the owner, who welcomed us as well. We visited May 6, 2018 - Don't miss this Deeelicious gem! I want to go back for another cone - all the way from the Poconos!!More