If you are from a large Metropolitan area, and are use to authentic Italian pizza. The is the place.
1 - 10 of 31 reviews
If you know good pizza, this place isn't it. I should have known, based on how few people were there on a weekend day. Pizza quality was poor, compared to good NY pizzas. Service slow. Place was clean, except the bathroom.
My husband and I came from ON Canada for the weekend of Aug4/6 for NASCAR at Watkins Glen...we ended up staying in Ithaca...everything else in the area was too pricey🙄After the race on Sunday, we came back late, but just were wanting a quick pizza.....More
Sal's is a commons cornerstone. Pizza is good, hot and has outside seating. Lots of choices to order only down side is that parking for pickup can be tough.
The best pizza around!! We got sausage and pepperoni and it was great! We go here every chance we get to either eat in or take home. They also have other Italian dishes.
This was the worst pizza I ever had. We ordered a large with mushrooms and spinach and it was totally tasteless! Being on a fixed income, the $21 I spent really hurt and I have no idea how to make the leftovers palatable enough to...More
This place makes great Italian, whether it's a pizza, hot wings, meatball sub, or ziti!!! Everything is piping hot and delicious!!! And the staff is wonderful. The shop is kept clean and fresh. Mostly we order delivery, which is probably the quickest in town, and...More
We just wanted to make a quick stop while passing through Ithaca, and figured college towns would have good pizza. Sal's did not dissappoint. It's not fancy. It's just a pizza joint. But it has good pizza that you can buy by the slice, which...More
I ordered take-out, because it was getting late. I ordered at 9:30, and they delivered to the hotel nearby. The delivery was timely. The food was okay. I ordered the chicken parmesan. There were several pieces of chicken, really too many. It did not include...More