So many flavors to choose from!! They all sound amazing. Everything is homemade and the waffle cones are amazing. Great place to stop!!
1 - 10 of 244 reviews
It is small inside and if warm you can sit outside. Maybe 4 tables. Hoffman hot dogs are different and awesome. Many good flavors of ice cream too. Nice small lunch place where there are not many places to eat around here. Stopped for lunch...More
We really enjoyed our dessert break at Cayuga Lake Creamery. We got the Spiced Apple flavor and it was excellent; the taste and texture felt very high quality and homemade. Would definitely come back next time we are in the area!
The creamery used to be terrific but today we had two cones for just under 10 dollars that were the worst ice cream we have ever tasted. My wife had a peach that had no peaches, did not taste or smell peachy and was overall...More
This little family owned ice cream shop has something for everyone. They have hard packed and soft serve ice cream as well as food. There were tons of choices for ice cream and some very unusual (wine ice cream). Scoops are very large and can...More
We had 2 different flavors and a sundae. Everything was absolutely generic, sub par, cheapest ice cream you can imagine. So disappointing. Thus was the spot we Always took our kids when doing wine tasting. We thought it was the best ice cream parlor in...More
Great spot for a summer dinner - pulled pork, burgers, etc. The dill pickle as a menu item surprised me, but they seem to sell a lot of them. Save room for dessert - the ice cream is fantastic. Personal favorites are the black raspberry,...More
This place has a bunch of ice cream flavors and was full of locals. It was good but it wasn't life changing. The "regular" size cone had more ice cream on it than I've eaten in a year; I wasn't able to eat even half...More