We walked in and were greeted by the friendly hostess and waitress. The restaurant is a cozy nook on Lake Cayuga. There is a choice of tables and booths. The food was good and reasonable. I would definitely return.
1 - 10 of 98 reviews
O'Malley's serves great Irish and bar food. They have friendly and wonderful staff who are helpful when choosing what to eat. We spent the weekend in the Finger Lakes and ended up at O'Malley's twice!
We finished a long drive and were too tired to drive far for dinner so decided to stop here as it was pretty much the only restaurant in the area. The lobster bisque was pretty good but everything else we had was disappointing. My wife's...More
Was during off hours and we wanted a little something to tide us over until dinner as we missed lunch. The setting on the lake and the log cabin are charming. They allowed us to share a sandwich and a dozen steamed clams without batting...More
Nice simple, straight forward menu, well prepared. Daily specials, especially the soups, were very good.
Perfect setting---able to boat to it--outdoor seating--cute log cabin atmosphere--burgers--sandwiches--full meals. Ful bar--casual setting--MAKE RESERVATIONS in summer!
Perfect dinner on a wooden deck overlooking Lake Cayuco with large family group. Great menu with something for everyone, including veggie choices. Fantastic waitstaff. Outstanding selection of local Upstate New York wines. Very casual.
Came here for dinner after a long 6 hour drive to vacation in the Finger Lakes. Food was average but service was extremely slow. Had to track down my waitress who was chatting in the bar with a local customer. She apologized.... but will not...More
Good food with great quantities. We went on crab leg night. We were amazed a the amount of food. It tasted good. The atmosphere was homey and there was a large outdoor space available for dining!
We have been going to O'Malley's during the summer months for several years and we used to enjoy it. This year things have definitely changed. We had dinner there about three weeks ago and the food was the pits. Four out of four said their...More