We noticed that you're using an unsupported browser. The Tripadvisor website may not display properly.We support the following browsers:
Windows: Internet Explorer, Mozilla Firefox, Google Chrome. Mac: Safari.
Get food delivered

Ratings and reviews



Special Diets
Vegetarian Friendly
Lunch, Dinner
View all details
meals, features
Reviews (34)
Filter reviews
33 results
Traveler rating
Traveler type
Time of year
Traveler rating
Show reviews that mention
All reviews eggplant parm pizza family style italian donuts chocolate sauce saturday night
Selected filters
Updating list...
Reviewed February 20, 2020 via mobile

Today was the first time we tried Eatalia. The lunch menu is extensive and inexpensive, but even better our food was delicious!

Date of visit: February 2020
Reviewed October 5, 2019 via mobile

We tried an appetizer and Lasagna to go. The stuffed mushrooms were great. The family style Lasagna for 2 was really just two basic pieces of lasagna. That Lasagna was kind of average. A little heavy on the sausage and light on sauce. It seemed...like not their best showing, we'll try it again.More

Date of visit: October 2019
Reviewed September 30, 2019

We had the pleasure of dining at Eatalia on a recent Saturday night. We were surprised for a nice Saturday night in Huntington that there was no wait at about 7pm, but we certainly didn't mind. It's family style so we just split a lovely...salad for one, which was more than enough for two. We also split one of the best eggplant parm dishes we had ever had. We always measure italian restaurants by their eggplant parm and this was one of if not the best we ever had. For dessert, omg, italian donuts with cannoli cream and chocolate sauce. Yes, it's as good as it sounds. Thank you to everyone at Eatalia for a wonderful dinner.More

Date of visit: September 2019
Reviewed August 17, 2019

Don't usually like to give such a poor rating to a locally owned business it in this case it fits... Stopped in for a quick couple of slices. it was after six and our usual pizza place on Wall St. was packed so we thought...we would give Eatalia a try. First clue we should've eaten elsewhere was the fact that the restaurant was empty. Not a soul. We were in a bit of a rush so we ordered a couple of slices. Clue number two was that the few pizzas that were on the counter looked like they were there all day. The pizza, as expected wasn't very good, not much cheese or sauce and the crust was like cardboard. Worst ever! I now understand why the dining room was empty and there are so few reviews.More

Date of visit: August 2019
Reviewed September 29, 2018

I've been here before and it's been decent but not even close tonight. Found out that sitting at a table you cannot order a large pie. Instead they have these things called pizzetta's which are mini pizzas so we ordered 2 as appetizers and they...came out after the rest of our food. Not only that, but they were smaller than the small pan they were served on and the dough was raw on the crust. We sent them back and the manager wouldn't come over to apologize to us or offer us anything else. The waitress also almost spilled an entire bowl of hot soup on my daughter trying to pass the soup over my daughter's head to my wife. Eventually they decided to take the pizzetta's off the bill - which are $14 for a 8 inch undercooked pie. Go to Portofino and get a large pie for $1 more and nice people. Never going here again.More

Date of visit: September 2018
Reviewed August 27, 2018

We love Eatalia ! The pizza is excellent but we have dined there over 20 times and keep going back !! The food is great, I love the fish dish,,so fresh and so tasty ! Excellent lunch special prices .. popular with large families on...weekends..generous portions and excellent service ! Great Great Great Espresso Martinis !! Try it you will love it !!More

Date of visit: August 2018
Reviewed July 29, 2018

Used a Groupon to try out Eatalia on a weekday evening in June. The restaurant was completely empty at 6:00 PM, but the host and waiter were extremely helpful and attentive. Ordered the fried calimari and baked clams as appetizers. For entrees we got the...crab and lobster ravioli, shrimp parmagiana and chicken marsala. Everything was excellent and the family style dishes let us all try a little bit of everything.More

Date of visit: June 2018
Reviewed July 9, 2018 via mobile

We booked a table for 10 people as we were celebrating my son's graduation earlier in the day. We weren't sure how long the ceremony was going to take and called back several times to adjust the time of our reservation. Each different person we...spoke to could not have been more accommodating. Food can be family style or individual servings. We opted for family style but were worried if it would be enough food. There was plenty of food to take home. We got fried mozzarella for apps, chicken parmigiana, gnocchi, and penne a la vodka as entrees. All were delicious. The penne could have used some salt, but that is a very minor critique. Overall, we were very happy with the food. We had my sister's grandson there who is a little over 2. He was a handful. But the place was loud, thankfully, and very accommodating. We went back a week later for the chicken parm and were just as happy. We were really happy to find this place and would definitely reccomend eating hereMore

Date of visit: June 2018
Reviewed June 1, 2018

we've been here several times & have enjoyed every visit. The waitstaff team is great, from Vincent, to Brandon to our waitress tonight, Brittany. Very pleasant an attention. We usually get an app/salad, split a pasta & get our own entree's. Tonight we agreed on...a entrée to split along with a salad. We each split the single salad family size entrée: Roasted Pepper Salad w/almonds, apples, gorgonzola, roasted pepper vinaigrette & Chicken Florentine, Spinach, prosciutto, mozzarella, sherry sauce. Salad for 1 was def big enough for 2 & the family size chicken dish had 5 pieces. Both were really tasting & filling !!! After dinner walked 10 feets to Ps & Qs bar, separate review.More

Date of visit: June 2018
Reviewed February 5, 2018

My gf and I went to Eatalia on a Saturday night. It was kind of late, so there were plenty of tables. Even though it was late, we were still served wonderfully. All our dishes were served beautifully and with perfection. We each had a...single salad which was enough for two people. We didn't even finish them. They were even pretty to look out. We shared the salmon dish which was good. It was served with spinach. Perhaps it was slightly over cooked but it was still good. The best part of the meal was the italian donuts. OMG. It is two pastries, huge ones, filled with canoli cream on a plate drizzed with chocolate sauce. There is also powdered sugar and plenty of chocolate chips on the plate. It was one of the best desserts I ever had, well worth breaking my diet for a night. Thank you to everyone there. We will be back.More

Date of visit: February 2018
View more reviews
Best nearby
Best nearby hotelsSee all
Rodeway Inn
128 reviews
2.91 miles away
OHEKA CASTLE Hotel & Estate
356 reviews
3.04 miles away
Chalet Inn & Suites
75 reviews
3.12 miles away
Whitman Motor Lodge
270 reviews
3.13 miles away
Best nearby restaurantsSee all
The Shed Restaurant - Huntington NY
71 reviews
.06 miles away
Swallow Restaurant
106 reviews
.05 miles away
64 reviews
.08 miles away
Honu Kitchen & Cocktails
140 reviews
.05 miles away
Best nearby attractionsSee all
The Paramount
310 reviews
.06 miles away
The Heckscher Museum of Art
84 reviews
.45 miles away
Huntington Public Library
8 reviews
.17 miles away
AMC Shore 8
28 reviews
.21 miles away
Questions & Answers
Ask a question
November 2, 2016|
Response from justgotravel | Reviewed this property |
I just tried it and worked for me. If you continue to have a problem the restaurant's number is 6316294551.
Is This Your Listing?
Own or manage this property? Claim your listing for free to respond to reviews, update your profile and much more.
Claim Your Free Listing