As the title says, only one meal out of three was very good. The mussels appetizer was very good. The "AB Hamburger" was a bit above average, but didn't quite make it to very good. Meatballs were interesting, but also didn't make it to very...good. The only drink we ordered was a coke. I got a small glass filled with ice and maybe 3 ounces of drink. I was going to order another, without ice, but our waitress neither asked if I wanted another drink nor cleared the empty glass from the table. The atmosphere was lively and the space we finally wound up in was attractive. However, the hostess wanted to seat us at a table next to a service hallway the looked very unattractive and also away from the pretty decor. After we let them know we were not going to sit there, they found a better table for us.
Take the online web menu as a rough guide only. That menu listed whole Branzino and Duck Leg Confit. The printed menu we received at the restaurant had only 6 entrees listed, none of which were Branzino or duck.
Greenport is a fun town and we'll probably try some of the other restaurants before returning to American Beech.More