We stopped here on a fluke and we were not disappointed. The food was average, the service was excellent. I was in the mood for soup and had beef barley. My husband had a pasta dish and said it was good, but wished they had...More
1 - 10 of 16 reviews
This restaurant serves a large variety of foods from Itaian to American to fish fries and most is good, Dinners are served w/potato and vegetable or with salad and soup bar. Good for families with kids meals on menu.
So our family ordered takeout and it was probably for the best because we might have given things back. Here is a rundown: Fried Shrimp - overcooked and it seemed like the oil doesn't get changed very often. It didn't come with cocktail sauce and...More
Being on the Island for 10 days we were looking for a new place to eat. We walked into the Town Cafe and two minutes later we walked right back out. I cannot give a fair assessment of the food or the service so I...More
We were a table of 11 Very slow service, some were almost done eating before the rest were served. Some orders were not correct done will not go back A little dingy
Buffalo is famous for fish fries and the Town Cafe is our regular place to go on Fridays. Lots of food and very reasonable prices. Service is always good. We prefer the "breaded" and not the beer battered fish and you get your choice of...More
12 years ago when we moved to the island, we ordered take out from town cafe. It was the worst fish and fries I ever ate. So we were very reluctant to give them another try. I am so glad we did. The food and...More
We got into town late and this was one of the few restaurants open. Although they had to check with the kitchen to see if they would serve us and said they could. We all had the hot beef sandwich with gravy and mashed potatoes....More
We had the fish fry, I would say that Serene Gardens and the Beach House have a much better Fish Fry. Their menu was also all over the place... are they a diner, a bar, a cafe, Italian food, greek...