We noticed that you're using an unsupported browser. The Tripadvisor website may not display properly.We support the following browsers:
Windows: Internet Explorer, Mozilla Firefox, Google Chrome. Mac: Safari.
Order Online

Ratings and reviews



American, Bar, Pub
Lunch, Dinner, Late Night
Takeout, Outdoor Seating, Seating, Television, Wheelchair Accessible, Serves Alcohol, Full Bar, Table Service, Reservations


Gandy Mozzarella Bread
Toasted garlic bread topped w/ melted mozzarella & served w/ a side of marinara for dipping.
Locomotive Loaded Fries
French fries smothered w/ melted cheddar jack cheese, chopped bacon, chives & sour cream.
Boomer Bruschetta Bread
Fresh diced tomatoes, basil & garlic topped w/ shaved parmesan cheese on sliced baguette.
A-Train Artichoke Dip
A creamy blend of spinach, artichokes, & cheese, served steaming hot w/ homemade tortilla chips, & garnished w/ diced tomatoes & green onions.
Train Wreck Nachos
House made tortilla chips loaded w/ melted cheese, beef, green onions, black olives & jalapenos. Served w/ salsa & sour cream.
Ballast Buffalo Wing Dip
Homemade wing dip, made w/ cream cheese, frank’s hot sauce & pulled chicken meat. Served w/ our homemade tortilla chips, garnished w/ green onions.
Peddler Portabella
Grilled jumbo portabella mushroom topped w/ cooked spinach, roasted red peppers & cheese blend, then drizzled w/ our homemade pesto sauce.
Brakeman Banana Peppers
Banana peppers stuffed w/ a fiery blend of sausage, ground beef, crushed red pepper & cheeses. Served w/ a slice of specialty bread.
Muzzle Loader Meatballs
Three juicy meatballs served on freshly sliced mozzarella, garnished w/ fresh arugula, sundried tomatoes & drizzled w/ our house made bourbon sauce.
Conductor's Caponatina
Breaded eggplant, fried golden brown, layered w/ sliced fresh mozzarella, topped w/ homemade pesto sauce & olive tapenade. Plated w/ fresh arugula.
Riley Street Soup of the Day
Made fresh daily, ask your server for details.
Cup $3.00
Bowl $4.00
Dinning Car Seasonal Soup
Seasonally available soup selection, ask server for details.
Foamer French Onion Soup
Caramelized onions in a savory chicken & beef stock. Served in a crock, topped w/ sliced baguette, & covered in a baked parmesan swiss cheese blend. Garnished w/ parsley flakes.
Gumshoe Grilled House Salad
Grilled red‏ onions, tomatoes, & feta, on a bed of mixed greens.
Side salad $5.00
Dinner salad $8.00
Spinach Speeder Salad
Red onions, black olives, & crumbled feta cheese placed on top of a bed of fresh spinach, w/ hard boiled egg, & served w/ sliced pita. Topped w/ our homemade bacon dressing.
Crosshead Caesar Salad
Fresh romaine lettuce tossed w/ our own garlic vinaigrette. Topped w/ croutons, grated parmesan cheese & served w/ an anchovy garnish.
Caprese Caboose Salad
Fresh mozzarella, tomatoes & mixed greens, seasoned w/ pesto & served w/ sliced baguette.
Signal Box Souvlaki Salad
Marinated chicken or beef served atop a bed of lettuce, w/ diced tomatoes, red onions, feta cheese, black olives, peperoncinis, & tzatziki sauce. Served w/ a toasted pita.
Piper Prairie Salad
Sliced pineapples, mandarin oranges, almonds, & goat cheese over a bed of mixed greens, served w/ homemade poppy seed dressing.
Amcan Antipasto Salad
Mixed greens tossed w/ brown sugar ham, smoked turkey, pepperoni, genoa salami, provolone, mozzarella, cheddar cheese, mixed banana peppers, black olives & cherry peppers. Choice of dressing.
Ticket Taker Taco Grande
Seasoned ground beef, cheddar jack, lettuce, fresh diced tomatoes, salsa & sour cream wrapped up burrito style in a flour tortilla. Served w/ homemade tortilla chips & salsa.
Seasonal vegetables $+1.50
Main Iron Beef on Weck
Slow roasted, tender roast beef piled high on a kimmelweck. Served w/ fries & a pickle.
Seasonal vegetables $+1.50
Rip Track Chicken Wrap
Grilled chicken‏ breast wrapped in a flour tortilla w/ cheddar jack cheese, mixed greens, tomatoes, & creamy ranch dressing. Served w/ fries & a pickle
Seasonal vegetables $+1.50
Boiler Buffalo Wrap
Grilled chicken breast, wrapped in flour tortilla w/ cheddar jack cheese, iceberg lettuce, tomatoes, choice of hot sauce & blue cheese dressing. Served w/ fries & a pickle
Seasonal vegetables $+1.50
Piston Portabella Stack
Open face stack of grilled zucchini, summer squash, roasted red pepper & portabella mushroom on top of a slice of toasted garlic bread. Served w/ choice of dressing.
Seasonal vegetables $+1.50
Railcar Reuben
Tender corned beef, sauerkraut, swiss cheese, & thousand island dressing grilled & served on sliced rye bread. Served w/ fries & a pickle.
Seasonal vegetables $+1.50
Push Car Puff Tilapia
A filet of tender white fish in a light puff batter w/ lettuce, tomato, & tartar sauce on toasted roll. Served w/ fries.
Seasonal vegetables $+1.50
Pullman Steak Philly
Choice of 12-inch steak or chicken sub w/ sautéed peppers, mushrooms, onions & topped w/ melted provolone. Served w/ fries & a pickle.
6-inch Philly $+7.00
Seasonal vegetables $+1.50
Cabin Car Quesadilla
Grilled chicken breast, cheddar jack cheese, diced tomatoes, green onions in a grilled flour tortilla, served w/ salsa & sour cream.
Seasonal vegetables $+1.50
Sill Car Sicilian Chicken
Grilled chicken breast, w/ pepperoni, ham & provolone cheese on toasted foccaccia. Topped w/ bruschetta mix, lettuce, caesar mayonnaise & served w/ fries & pickle.
Seasonal vegetables $+1.50
All burgers served w/ a side of French fries, pickle & topped w/ lettuce, tomato & onions.
Riley Street Classic Burger
Our signature ½pound burger, handmade, never frozen & always fresh. charbroiled to your liking over an open flame, served on a fresh roll. topped w/ American cheese.
Mogul Mushroom & Swiss Burger
Our signature‏ homemade burger w/ sautéed mushrooms & melted swiss cheese.
Hickory Smokebox Burger
Our signature homemade burger, topped w/ cheddar cheese, sliced ham, crisp bacon & BBQ sauce.
Bulkhead Bacon & Blue Burger
Our signature‏ homemade burger w/ crisp bacon & crumbly blue cheese.
Short Ton Animal Style Burger
Our signature‏ homemade burger w/ caramelized onions, thousand island dressing, & melted American cheese.
Wigwag Hot & Spicy Burger
Our signature homemade burger w/ sautéed mushrooms, jalapenos, banana peppers, & pepper jack cheese.
Blastpipe Bruschetta Burger
Our signature homemade burger, topped w/ our fresh house made bruschetta mix & parmesan cheese.
Turntable Taco Burger
Our signature homemade burger flavored w/ taco seasoning, topped w/ salsa, pepper jack cheese & sour cream.
Union Pacific Patty Melt
Our signature homemade burger topped w/ American cheese, caramelized onions, served between two slices of rye bread & pan grilled w/ butter.
Classic Riley Street Pizza
Classic style 16” pizza, w/ house made pizza sauce, topped w/ mozzarella cheese & pepperoni.
Hickory BBQ Pizza
16” pizza, w/ hickory BBQ sauce, cheddar cheese mix, apple wood bacon, brown sugar ham & pineapple slices.
Italian Pie Pizza
16” pizza, w/ house made pizza sauce, sliced tomatoes, onions, touch of garlic & blended Italian cheeses.
Alfredo Primavera Pizza
16” pizza,‏ w/ our house made alfredo sauce, shaved parmesan, touch of mozzarella & garlic. Topped w/ red onions, diced tomatoes, broccoli & summer squash.
Meat Lovers Pizza
16” pizza, w/ house made pizza sauce, topped w/ boneless pieces of chicken tossed in franks hot sauce, w/ seasoned ground chuck, apple wood bacon & pepperoni.
Chessie Chicken Fingers
Crispy jumbo‏ chicken fingers tossed in your choice of sauce, served w/ sides of fries, blue cheese & celery.
Char-bq $+0.50
Short Line Shrimp Basket
Yuengling beer battered shrimp, deep fried & tossed in your choice of hot sauce. Served w/ fries & coleslaw.
Freight Line Fajitas
Seasoned chicken or beef on a sizzling fajita pan w/ onions, peppers, mushrooms & warm tortillas. Served w/ cheddar jack cheese, lettuce, tomatoes, sour cream & salsa.
B&O Baby Back Ribs
Our fork-tender, fall of the bone ribs covered w/ our dry rub seasoning. served w/ coleslaw & French fries.
Half rack $15.00
Full rack $21.00
For smaller appetites
Handcar Hot Dog & Fries
Sahlen’s hot dog charbroiled & served w/ a side fries.
Pennsy Pasta Plate
Penne pasta, w/ choice of marinara or butter sauce.
Garratt Grilled Cheese
Grilled cheese‏ sandwich, served w/ fries & a pickle.
C&O Chicken Fingers
Small order of the chessie chicken fingers tossed in choice of sauce, served w/ fries, blue cheese, celery & carrots.
Classic Chicken Wings
Fresh jumbo wings tossed in your choice of sauce. Choose from hot, medium, mild, BBQ or hot-bq.
Single order $9.00
Double order $16.00
Char-BBQ Wings
BBQ or hot-bq wings fried, tossed in sauce, then charbroiled for that extra right of the grill flavor.
Single order $9.50
Double order $17.00
Honey BBQ Wings
Smokey BBQ sauce & sweet honey.
Single order $10.00
Double order $18.00
Honey Cajun Wings
Homemade cajun seasoning & sweet honey.
Single order $10.00
Double order $18.00
Honey Mustard Wings
Dijon mustard & sweet honey.
Single order $10.00
Double order $18.00
Smoking Hot Suicide Wings
Fiery cajun seasoning, w/ frank’s & butter.
Single order $10.00
Double order $18.00
Garlic Parmesan Wings
Garlic, basil, frank’s, butter & parmesan cheese.
Single order $10.00
Double order $18.00
Sicilian Parmesan Wings
Garlic, basil, butter & parmesan cheese.
Single order $10.00
Double order $18.00
Greek Athena Wings
Garlic, basil, butter & sweet honey.
Single order $10.00
Double order $18.00
Tiger Sauce Wings
Ketchup, mustard, hot sauce & butter.
Single order $10.00
Double order $18.00
Served after 4pm daily
All entrees include fresh bread & choice of a grilled house salad or cup of soup
‘manhattan limited’ NY strip steak
Manhattan limited, serving: Chicago il, washington d.c., New York city USAD choice cuts grilled to your liking. served w/ a side of potato & seasonal vegetables. topped w/ an onion ring.
8 ounce $21.00
12 ounce $27.00
Grilled house salad
Cup of soup
‘Mt. Vernon’ Twin Peaks Sirloin
The mt. Vernon, serving: Chicago il, washington d.c., New York city New York strip steak, topped w/ seasoned mashed potatoes & a demi-glaze gravy, served w/ seasonal vegetable.
8 ounce $22.00
12 ounce $28.00
Grilled house salad
Cup of soup
‘Nellie Bly’ Grilled Salmon
The Nellie BLY, serving: atlantic city, NJ & New York city fresh char grilled salmon filet, served w/ potatoes, seasonal vegetable & topped w/ a lemon herb butter sauce.
Grilled house salad
Cup of soup
‘Keystone’ Mussel Linguini w/ Clam Sauce
the keystone, serving: washington d.c., New York city creamy white wine clam sauce, seasoned w/ garlic, fresh parsley & red pepper flakes. topped w/ shaved parmesan cheese & steamed mussels, tossed in linguini pasta.
Grilled house salad
Cup of soup
‘Buffalo Day’ Chicken Marsala
Buffalo day express, serving: washington d.c., Philadelphia pa, buffalo NY boneless chicken breast sautéed in olive oil, w/ shitake mushrooms, fresh garlic, a touch of pepper & finished w/ a marsala wine sauce. served w/ potato & vegetable.
Grilled house salad
Cup of soup
‘South Wind’ Jamaican Jerk Pork Chops
The south wind, serving: Chicago il, Louisville KY, Miami fl pan seared boneless pork chops, flavored w/ our house made jamaican jerk seasoning. garnished w/ pineapple relish, served w/ potato & vegetable.
Grilled house salad
Cup of soup
‘Broadway Limited’ Italian Broil
Broadway limited, serving: Chicago il, washington d.c., New York city a broiled filet of fresh haddock, topped w/ toasted Italian bread crumbs, our special bruschetta topping, & an shaved parmesan cheese.
Grilled house salad
Cup of soup
‘Dominion’ Fettuccine Alfredo
Dominion express, serving: washington d.c., Philadelphia pa, buffalo NY a rich creamy alfredo sauce, seasoned w/ butter, garlic, black pepper, parsley & parmesan cheese. tossed w/ fettuccini pasta.
Grilled house salad
Cup of soup
Reviews (156)
Filter reviews
156 results
Traveler rating
Traveler type
Time of year
Traveler rating
Show reviews that mention
All reviews burger salad ham sandwiches beef our server was very attentive winter months dining room is the wait staff building depot olives
Selected filters
Updating list...
Reviewed December 29, 2019 via mobile

The food is average. The restaurant is nice with big open windows and pretty Christmas decorations. Probably won’t go back.

Date of visit: December 2019
Reviewed October 22, 2019

My wife and I had dinner here and we were very pleased. A reservation is recommended and by 6 PM the place was packed. There is something on the menu for everyone and the prices are reasonable. Both of our meals were delicious and prepared...More

Date of visit: October 2019
Reviewed September 18, 2019

The back room is a great place to enjoy a meal - very picturesque. I ordered the Monte Cristo sandwich, one of my favorites. It did not disappoint - it was packed with ham, turkey and cheese, and was served with a cherry jam -...More

Date of visit: September 2019
Reviewed July 18, 2019

There were 4 of us today and three of the four had the same thing, The 4th had a small pizza. The main group had the Brie, Bacon and Apricot Jam sandwich with a Balsamic Glaze. I was not that thrill but my wife and...More

Date of visit: July 2019
Reviewed April 4, 2019

Very good food, back dining room is busy but nice, great service, nice view of back hill especially during the winter months

Date of visit: November 2018
Reviewed March 16, 2019

Went to this place with friends for the first time, bar was big enough lots of seating to have a drink before dinner. Average price bottled beer $4.00 we were there March 16th so it was all decorated for St. Patrick's Day. We were seated...More

Date of visit: March 2019
Reviewed January 6, 2019

Popular and noisy; good sandwiches, salads; very relaxed; loud, lively local (mostly young) crowd; service was excellent

Date of visit: January 2019
Reviewed November 4, 2018

Liking good food is a stop for many locals and out-of-towners. We (my wife and I) both like their Chicken Quesadilla which is tempting to look at when served but ever so lovely and tasteful to eat. Best to call for "Call-Ahead Seating Option." Only...More

Date of visit: October 2018
Reviewed September 2, 2018 via mobile

I'm a little disappointed it was our first time here and the restaurant is really cute. But the food was average my husband and I had a beef on weck and the beef was tender but it had absolutely no flavor nor did the au...More

Date of visit: September 2018
Reviewed July 24, 2018

Stopped in for a bite after a parade and were pleasantly surprised. It's a great little place with a super Roast beef sandwich and fries for only $11. We loved the atmosphere of this old Penn Railroad station now transformed into a delightful place to...More

Date of visit: July 2018
View more reviews
Best nearby
Best nearby hotelsSee all
Hampton Inn East Aurora
630 reviews
.27 miles away
Roycroft Inn
254 reviews
.30 miles away
Orchard Park Inn
18 reviews
5.96 miles away
Red Carpet Inn Orchard Park
35 reviews
9.26 miles away
Best nearby restaurantsSee all
Elm Street Bakery
301 reviews
.20 miles away
Roycroft Inn
273 reviews
.31 miles away
Rick's On Main
255 reviews
.16 miles away
42 North Brewing Company
64 reviews
.19 miles away
Best nearby attractionsSee all
Vidler's 5 & 10
284 reviews
.16 miles away
Roycroft Campus
134 reviews
.37 miles away
Millard Fillmore Museum
57 reviews
.52 miles away
Elbert Hubbard Roycroft Museum
33 reviews
.53 miles away
Questions & Answers
Ask a question
Sheila S
December 29, 2014|
AnswerShow all 4 answers
Response from ellsee74 | Reviewed this property |
I'm sure if you call the restaurant they would be happy to accommodate you and your party. They were very helpful to us during our visit. Hope you enjoy!
Is This Your Listing?
Own or manage this property? Claim your listing for free to respond to reviews, update your profile and much more.
Claim Your Free Listing