We noticed that you're using an unsupported browser. The TripAdvisor website may not display properly.We support the following browsers: Windows: Internet Explorer, Mozilla Firefox, Google Chrome. Mac: Safari.
All reviews pizza wings pie garlic knots salad spaghetti sandwiches great crust by the slice few blocks friendly service baseball hall of fame main street induction weekend visiting cooperstown toppings takeout
We recently had the opportunity to experience New York Pizzeria in Cooperstown. It was excellent from the moment we entered the establishment. The staff was super-friendly, service fast, and the food was amazing. Just the best. We highly recommend this local establishment. It's low key,...More
Feel like swine? This place looked nice and cozy and the staff seemed ok. Then we received the pizza and wings we ordered! The wings were in a puddle of what was called hot sauce but was nothing more than grease with no heat whatsoever!...More
Date of visit: August 2019
60JoeV, Owner at New York Pizzeria, responded to this reviewResponded 5 weeks ago
You’ve had pizza out of a Chef Boyardee Can??? Wow and it was better then ours. I’ll have to try it out. Canned pizza,, Must be new. From reading your reviews this is just an obvious attempt to bash the restraunt and knock us down...More
My wife and I were expecting NY style pizza but it was far from it. We decided it was not a bad pizza and we enjoyed it. We ordered the mushroom and sausage which was a little sweet for my taste but my wife liked...More