Great well done pizza. I love their coal fired pepperoni pizza and martini night on Wednesdays. Great service and always friendly. Commack location never has too much of a wait.
1 - 10 of 85 reviews
Visiting at 7 pm on a Wednesday evening, Anthony's was busy and noisy with a good atmosphere. The food was excellent; meat balls with ricotta and simply cooked wings to start, followed by a large half and half thin crust pizza (margarita one side with...More
I stopped into restaurant when I made a wrong turn. Never heard of the chain before. By the time I left, I was sold. The restaurant makes excellent pizza. I had the 16" large with mushrooms and sausage. While I waited I had a Peroni...More
This place is nice and quaint, the flavors are extraordinary and the prices are reasonable. The best thing on the menu is "Anthony's Favorite".
Anthony's does what they do very well. Go for the pizza, the wings and some alcohol and leave without breaking the bank and enjoying a very good meal. It's always busy for a reason. You won't be sorry. Nice setting as well and staff is...More
I've had excellent coal fired pizza here. The mozzarella and broccoli rabe is my favorite. The chicken wings with onion are unusual but very tasty. Decent craft beer selection and pretty good bar scene. One size fits all.
Anthonys is delicious! Great well done thin crust pizza and outrageous chicken wings! It is not inexpensive but well worth it!
We went here to try the food, but being a NY pizza consumer and very pick, I was not expecting to love it. It was very crowded when we arrived and we waited about 15 minutes for a table. Never haven't eaten here, we looked...More