Love the New England feeling of the island. We had perfectly prepared lobsters. A very plain meal but excellent.
1 - 10 of 81 reviews
We were looking forward to a delicious seafood lunch when we went to The Lobster Box. The decor was cute and the service was excellent. Unfortunately that did not make up for the food. The clam chowder was not thick, it was full of potatoes,...More
Visiting City Island has been on my bucket list for many years .My Physical Therapist suggested the Lobster Box as a restaurant for lunch .We were welcomed warmly and promptly seated. The menu listed a luncheon special:salad ,entree ,desert of the day and coffee or...More
I chose Lobster Box based on reviews, having never been to City Island and not knowing which place to eat at. The restaurant has plenty of parking. It reminds me of an old world restaurant, been around for a long time, nothing fancy. BUT oh...More
The best restaurant on City Island. You'll get the best food, the best service, and none of the other nonsense you see in some other establishment on the island. You will pay more than those other places, and it's worth every cent.
This place has the most yummy seafood! It's an experience not just dinner! Really friendly staff, a must for everyone!!
used to be a great place but most everything was mediocre. appetizers were fair, the spare ribs were tasteless (no good sauce), the calamari was obviously packaged previously frozen (like from Restaurant Depot in 5 lb bags), sauce for the calamari was very blah and...More