We’ve mostly eaten here for lunch. Very good choice. A nice atmosphere. Friendly waitstaff. Decent pricing.
1 - 10 of 67 reviews
Not my favorite pizza . The sauce is really acidic and seems to upset my stomach every time. The service is okay as well small hot To eat at the one in great Bend New York the one in Carthage is OK as well not...More
Food was excellent and customer service is always on point. The prices are a little high but you do get pretty big portions so that could be reasoning behind that. Overall the food is good and would recommend this to people coming thru town looking...More
We were back in Carthage to visit TF Wright's and stopped into Stefano's. My Wife had the Chicken & Roasted Red Petter Panini and I had the Calzone! Both were great, service was excellent, and the atmosphere was perfect. Their tomato sauce is dynamite!
We ordered a white pizza w/toppings and some wings, from restaurant in Great Bend NY. We really didn't order anything special. The wings were okay, but the pizza was not even close to what we ordered. It came as a three cheese. So we called...More
Excellent take out pizza and wings. Dine in for an extended Italian menu. Additional parking is in the rear if the street parking is full.
We ordered 2 large pizzas for our family and it was way more food than we expected. Very good quality, we will definitely return.
Carthage is a quiet place, with not a lot of dining options. So it was a pleasant surprise to find an Italian place down the street with pizza and pasta that could be successful in Brooklyn or Queens or New Haven. The pizza is consistently...More
We ordered the calzone and pizza. The food and service was excellent. I would highly recommend Stefano's for any event.
Local favorite makes great garlic knots and a good N.Y. style pizza. The salad is fresh and the balsamic dressing is great.